Blade's Mafia Game of Randomness

[SCRIBBLE]

We might have a lightning rod in play which redirected a kill and a protection. If done the first night it may be an x shot.

[StarsMine]

We might have a lightning rod in play which redirected a kill and a protection. If done the first night it may be an x shot.

Sounds more plausible then the other explinations

[Nemesis]

Cant rule out random Vig shootings because Mikey is playing.

I disagree that the flavour indicates anyone took a shot that hit a protected person.

I'm leaning towards a lightning rod or some form of that role.

[brett friggin favre]

i'd believe a lightning rod

[Passarelli]

Hmm, x shot lighting rod + doc seems a little strong, but is believable.

I'd enjoy hearing from those lurking in the background.

[What]

I don't love the idea of a lightning rod. I don't really see the flavor indicating that in anyway. Also, it would effectively mean that no one could trust anything they got from the night before, which I don't think is really true. If that is the case though, it essentially means we are shooting blind for Day 1.

[Passarelli]

Negative utility for the loss.

[CYBER]

I don't love the idea of a lightning rod. I don't really see the flavor indicating that in anyway. Also, it would effectively mean that no one could trust anything they got from the night before, which I don't think is really true. If that is the case though, it essentially means we are shooting blind for Day 1.

actually come to thing of it, the flavour DOES speak of "its just thunder"...

thunder?
lightning?
...

i take back my earlier shit, i like this shit a lot fucking better, and it would explain 1 or 2 ppl shooting shit, and someone using a protective role that was all redirected to save that one person...

[What]

Thunder could be an allusion to a lightning rod, though again in context that reads to me like someone trying to cover for someone else.
If we want to operate under the idea that there was a lightning rod night one, then we know for certain that there is a doctor in play, and not a bodyguard. The investigative role should have gotten a pro-town reading, and any type of watcher or voyeur would have gotten a very long read out.

Also, and again, it means we have no actionable information for the day.

[Nemesis]

I think we have to assume night 1 was a wash