Blade and Nem's IBIS Themed Mafia Game (Insanity Game #1)

[Trigger Unhappy]

Whoa, a lot to take in today. To me it seems Cyber is genuine in his claim. It sucks that he is, you have become useless to us now. You have entered untouchable territory. Unless You are a 3rd party survivor! Your hard claim makes more sense. Then you would benefit in a hard claim day 1 as the last fucker to kill. I am a newb, but that feels right to me.

I have not been here for all the past games you guys talk about. But I give you more credit than the early L-2 hard claim. With this being an insanity game, I would also think that a bomb would get some sort of x-shot ability.

Problem with this is he couldnt have known someone wouldnt counter claim him.

[Passarelli]

Scribble, I'll reply to you when I have a computer to organize quotes better. I should be home soon to do so.

BM, wtf other games am I playing? Carmageddon? I do my best to not do that.

I said I was going to let you and and the Mexican sit, mostly because I feel like Cyber could be right about you being a lyncher. I said a while ago I felt your play this game was fishy. I don't feel confident one way or the other about Cyber's claim to risk lynching him. I'd rather wait for the night and see if some sort of resolution can be reached on that subject day 2.

Your shit about 3rd parties is very wrong, BTW. Survivor sides with whatever side he thinks can win. Joker can quickhammer someone just to be scumtastic. Lychers and unlychers can be town sided, depending on their target, but aren't told their targets alignment for that reason. 3rd parties aren't on anyone's side but their own. This means unless the mod modified their win condition, they are anti-town (which is what they show up as when a cop investigates them). Anti-town = scum.

Looking at it a different way, we pretty much think it is likely 5v2v1. If we Lynch the 3rd party, it becomes 5v2. After night it is 4v2. If we mislynch, it becomes 4v2v1. After night it is 3v2v1 (if mafia doesn't hit 3rd party.

So day 2 with the 3rd party lynched it would be 4/6 town and 2/6 mafia.
With a mislynch it is 3/6 town and 2/6 mafia.

Mafia would stay the same, but town would be at a lower ratio.

Finally, if what you said were true in that 3rd parties are essentially town, it would actually be better to no Lynch, as towns odds go up in 5v2 compared to 6v2.

You pushed yourself harder into 3rd party in my mind with your argument.

That said, it is still better to try for mafia and let the 3rd party sit.

- - - Updated - - -

Jesus fuck. Crit wall of text

[StarsMine]

I dont buy blackmage is a lyncher for a second.

[Blackmage]

Problem with this is he couldnt have known someone wouldnt counter claim him.

Are you talking about his claim of bomb? Because you can be as sure no one would CC that as you can with anything.

Pass, it's your crap like this:

If you compare blackmage in this game to previous ones, his day 1 is very very aggressive this game

All you had to do is point out the vast change in his gameplay. He has never been this aggressive day 1 on a specific person.

I, for one, am playing the insanity game. I am not playing whatever games you think I am. The same thing Cyber is saying. We don't play each game the same, and it just hurts your position and logic to think so.

[StarsMine]

No one would CC bomb because its a fucking stupid claim. If his claim is true he totally screwed town with it. Why would someone else want the blame of fucking over town? If blackmage is a lyncher, who cares, we still go for who we think is mafia.

- - - Updated - - -

If there is someone who can CC the bomb, they should keep their mouth shut so mafia can blow themselves up on him.

[CYBER]

soooooooo... am i the only one noticing that starsmine's been particularly protective of Blackmage for a while now?
Not only based on his recently not to subtle posts, but the fact that he STILL had no logical reason of why he jumped on the wagon that blackmage pulled on me, and then chalked it off to an "accidental whoops, didnt know it was that far in the wagon" ?

seriously, am i the only fucking sane person seeing this shit.

[Assassin]

I've noticed a few trends. Scribble deflecting and not really saying shit is one of em

[Blackmage]

Ass, who has said anything useful? There was a conversation about claiming bomb, and a conversation about 3rd party. One is something about a bad play, the other about speculation. Again, we have no new votes, so no new pressure, so nothing to talk about. I've said it before, but people need to vote so we can continue the day. 2 votes on Cyber and I'll lynch (or 1, and I'll throw on to prove about double voters), a pair of votes on any one of 3 people and we're in threat range, or 3 votes on the 4 voteless people.

[SCRIBBLE]

Give me an example of what has been deflected. You have asked me zero questions. The only thing you have done is made baseless accusations. You have done nothing more than what you claim I am doing.

Also, I'm still waiting on pass to give me a run down of my quiet pushing and lackluster rhetoric.

I have been nothing but firm in my stance against cyber and not once have I tried to hide it.

[Passarelli]

Shit came up irl (metal in tire) so I'm not going to make it home. Basically it's just how I see your posts. Pretty subjective, but enough that I'd make the first vote on you day 1.

- - - Updated - - -

By the by, if nothing else I'll be home Saturday for sure if you really want the play by play.