Mafia Game: Donner Party 2: Don Harder

[SCRIBBLE]

I am suspect of stars, blade, and zambi.

Especially stars.

I will write up a more detailed post in a few hours once my day calms down and give the thread a once over.

[Rosie]

Unless it was just luck, Zambi did not vote on the day1 mislynch. Which leaves my FOS on Blade, Stars and Scrib.

[CYBER]

And here where you went so far as to (try to) vote him.

I understand Trig being on the list after day 1, but if it's not a 180, where's the feint I missed, and why did you go so far? You were talking day 1 as if he was your major target and now he's not even in your top four.

If he's mafia, couldn't his teammate walk him through it? They have day talk. Didn't people do something similar with Mikey and an Arsonist? Also, new? After playing here for over a year and around 10 games, that's... Kind of insulting.

If you could show me what changed, I'd be grateful. Where there was a problem day 1, you have now brushed it off day 2, and I'm curious why. With little information, I'd love to have somewhere to start, and with Pass dead, and my suspecting Blade, I find yours is the most rational voice.

Also, looking at things, you were at L-2, not L-1 when Trig made his comment. Fairly sure this will not change anything, as the point was the words used, but going to put that out there just in case.

Again, at the time, stars misinforming town (much similar to Zambi btw, they're both equally tagged with the same misbehavior) , but stars to a greater extent.
So in my mind back then, it just felt like Stars was playing dumb early on when he was talking about the vig, it just felt like he intentionally made a mistake when talking about the vig to see who will be the first person to correct him, and that person is usually the vig ( i cant tell you if that was his thinking, or if he can actually think about it that way to begin with)
but I have been reading a lot recently on dumbtells and common tells to try to get a vibe on who's who, and it worked for the other game.
But in this game it felt like stars tried to bait out the first person to reply to a vig comment, much like how the first person to congratulate the doctor in mafia games is commonly either the doctor himself or scum. So THAT alone just stuck in my head.
Over the course of the day afterwards, that feeling kept bothering me and thats why i was very suspicious of stars, and trigger did a similar tell as well. So between the choice of stars and trigger (if i couldn't vote for both that day) i ended up moving on to the trigger wagon because stars's mistakes and misinformation became increasingly DUMBER and outrageous, to the point where it felt like I couldn't think he was faking it anymore...

That being said, you did just remind me of the fact that mafia has day talk and he could be being babysat all day.... but right now, unles there's like a superwagon on stars that could help clear some info, then i'm just trying to put stars aside and try to prod other things, because the hidden deaths are just making it harder to guess alliances until we get a cannibal killed.

[StarsMine]

You guys sure are reading alot into me not knowing the unique shit in Don party

[Blackmage]

Stars: When someone doesn't understand what's going on, they're less useful to the game, because it forces you to take what they say with a grain of salt, and not because they might be scum. Plus, after you not knowing something major day one, and being linked to the layout, being confused day two seems to be either malicious or willful ignorance.

Cyber: Thanks for the clarification.

[What]

Daytalk makes me think Stars isn't being coached since he got defensive with his ignorance and not just "oh I didn't know." That being said, with anyone else it would make me very suspicious but this is the guy who mentioned artillery fire in the spyfall game, so it really may not be an act.

Rosie's comment yet again makes little sense in regards to Zambi. Judging from how he finished off the last game, generally with him it seems that where there is smoke there is fire.

Blade I don't like, since he is literally bringing nothing to the table, doing nothing at all in general, and he seems like the kind of guy who picks a kind of character or style at the beginning and just roles with it for the lulz.

[BladeTwinSwords]

Well what else am I supposed to do. I would bring more to the table except I don't really have much. The best I can do is give my suspicions but that's all.

[What]

The game needs chatter, its the only way to gain information that, if not immediately helpful, can prove significant down the road. Your position is essentially, if you are a VT or a power role that got nothing, just sit still and don't say anything. I can't see how that will lead to anything other than days that take weeks at a time until people get so bored of it they just vote to end the agony.

[CYBER]

alright then.
strike 2.

unvote.

Vote Zambi.

reason? Well i posted it above but he did misinform town originally, but not drastically enough to be "too dumb to fake".

His original involvment with the Vig talks, then sudden quietness, then direct replies to prodded posts only, it's just a bit off.
I literally PAINTED zambi as our vig yesterday, which should have put a mark on his back, but he came out of the night unscratched, and I find that peculiar considering that there weren't any decent power role tells elsewhere for mafia/sk to follow up on.

His early involvement about the vig shot not going off if being killed felt out of the blue, and very awkward considering he's played quite the number of games so far and should know that all actions execute on a priority based system, but they all execute nonetheless, and the only way for an action to not go through is when specifically blocked.

I don't know, I just dislike that he's still alive and kicking when I spiced him up as a succulent vig wannabe bait, and mafia didn't bite , well, didnt bite HIM.

[StarsMine]

I probably should put down a vote just to keep the game moving, but I dont have any strong suspicions on anyone.

Vote BM