I have finally decided to say fuck it and bring up my ideas.

Town Vibe:

Cyber - Easily the most town to me based off his answers.
What - With the constant bitchfight between him and Blackmage convinced me he was fine.
TriggerMage - The fact that he got replaced makes me feel like Trigger was either Town or maybe SK.

Neutral Vibe:

Zambi - His answers sort of fit but I'm not sure.
Stars - Don't quite trust just yet since he's been all over the place in his responses.

Suspicious Vibe:

Scrib - I always suspect you based off your playstyle.
Rosie - The new person can easily be coached using Daytalk.