If you're too ignorant to know what number comes after five, god help us all.

- - - Updated - - -

I think I just figured it out, the piece you're missing! In this mode, when you choose someone D1, there's no reason not to just hammer them. In a normal game, unless you're bad, you should give them a chance to speak their piece, so you don't hammer a useful role D1. I forgot who I was having a discussion with.