All Along The Watchtower

[hippo]

a VT in this setup just doesn't make sense short of nemesis fucking with us.
it's too under Powered vs all the other roles. Hell he could have even given you the damn PA system for all he cared.
so you just straight up stayed home at night for the last 2 nights?

Yaw, I'm too lazy to do shit at night. And, from my understanding, VT's are essential for balancing. It's not a role madness game

[Passarelli]

wow pass, you right, it looks like an old cyber post, shit logic and all. At least this game cyber has been rather useful with his posts.

I'm super impressed by your counter points. I especially like how you pointed out how horribly bad the reasoning is as to why I think you are full of shit. Also, your alternative is a beautiful work of craftsmanship that will assuredly bring victory to town.

Oh wait, you did none of that. My bad.

From his shitty useless response and the fact that town is in rough shape ONLY if he is lying, I really want to Lynch him.

- - - Updated - - -

Also, I can give proof of my role (or at least one of my 1x abilities) or give you some semblance of protection.

And yes, I am the PA system. Jesus you are a numbskull sometimes, Cyber.

Sorry I missed those posits earlier.

[What]

Welcome to the realization that Stars is a barely functioning human Pass, it gets more fun from this point on.

Cyber has had several typos and mistakes in his posts, so, no Stars, just no. Also, I see you dropped the whole "I'm cleared" thing, it looks like its trying to learn guys!

Pass has a point. If Stars is lying, then town is in a bad way, and 3 people can die tonight. If he is telling the truth, on Phil is in danger, and that is not necessarily a bad thing. If he dies from fire and turns up scum, great, if its town, well we know that the arsonist is likely Zambi. We have numbers so we will be fine.

I don't know how well Hippo knows you Cyber, and the useless Cyber's mother thing does seem like a Nemesis thing. You said why would he do it if not just to fuck with us, and that would be your answer right there.

I want to wait for Phil's claim, but I do see the strategic value in taking out Stars.

[Passarelli]

If he is lying, and we lynch hippo, Phil and Blade will die tonight. I have 1x death immunity.

That would leave Cyber and What as town, Stars as arsonist, Zambi as a jester? and myself as survivor, so it would still maybe work out if zambi is a jester.

Lynching stars would replace him with hippo if he or zambi were the arsonist.

Phil is the 'safe' bet, as if he isn't the arsonist blade would also die, but no one else. So it'd be Cyber, What, Hippo, Stars, Zambi, and myself.

So yeah, those are the 3 options. Do you guys think we have another killer? If not, I could try stopping the match rather than protecting Cyber.

- - - Updated - - -

That said, I really think stars is the arsonist.

[CYBER]

It's fucking shitty that out of Stars, hippo, phil and zambi,
at least one town is being too much of a tard and comes off as scum.

Option 1:
Lynch Stars, investigate phil/hippo (zambi already claimed third party so investigating him is useless)

- If stars is arsonist, then based on result of my investigation we lynch accordingly (with zambi in mind)
But overall, good outcome.

- If stars firefighter. Baaad. I do same investigation on Phil/Hippo.
Arsonight will douse and ignite Phil and <other>. That person can, at worst case scenario, be a townie such as blade. This will put us at LyLo to hit BOTH killer scum roles on the back to back nights, otherwise we lose by tie to whichever is alive, due to pass's alignment being neutral.

If stars is anarchist, mafia loses, anarchist gets 2 ppl killed, worst case Phil and Town again like blade.
The difference between this point and just before, is that Town will be Me and What vs Arsonist vs Survivor vs zambi's jester claim.
We WILL be at MyLo since we'd have that day, and only the immediate following day to kill arsonist.

OPTION 2:
We lynch hippo who claims VT. investigate stars/phil.
The EXACT scenario as above, except he doesn't claim being firefighter, so the shittiest scenario is thankfully off the table, even if hippo WAS a VT...

OPTION 3:We lynch Phil. Investigate stars/hippo.
Same as option 2.

So keep in mind that Zambi's not new to this, and his jester hint is spot on because it adds the risk of lynching him.

Also keep in mind that i will get a result for investigation in all case scenarios.
If I hit a scum, then we are still at MyLo, because we lynch that person, but need to lynch the second one the day after if blade is dead.
If I hit a TOWN, then we finally can rest a little, because Then we would have the numbers between What, myself, and X person to actually sustain through the hit the following night.

So I really think that lynching stars is the LEAST favorable option.
Phil is the safest imho since he hasn't claimed VT, not has he given us anything worth a damn.

- - - Updated - - -

as you can see YET AGAIN, I very much think that the biggest threat in the game is arsonist right now vs the anarchist..until blade bites the dust.

[hippo]

I don't see how you all think I'm scummy. I helped encourage the Jiggly lynch first day, and he turned out Anarchist. Even if he's useless as a player, that's a strong role for mafia. I'm not Arsonist either, although I can't prove that until either I get doused or the Arsonist gets outed.

I think Phil hinted at having a protective-ish role but is avoiding a hard claim, probably because he doesn't want to be counterclaimed. Personally, I don't think anyone is clear, other than perhaps Cyber

[phil.™]

Either way, i'm a dead man, lynched on this day, or gonna die tomorrow.
I'm a town vigilante, with 1 shot each night. So hippo saying he's a "VT" ? a Vanilla?

So yeah, if you want a "safe" lynch and don't care about town, then goooooo right ahead and lynch me, don't listen to anything I have to say. Cause when the package is this pretty on the outside, nobody cares what's on the inside.

[StarsMine]

why would you die tomorrow?

- - - Updated - - -

Wait what package phil, you said you were doused, not that you had a package

[phil.™]

Wait what package phil, you said you were doused, not that you had a package

I was referring to a "Friends" quote. Joey Tribbiani. Nvm. You should watch it, it is a good episode.

[What]

No one said they got a package today, its possible we don't have another bomb giver and the only thing making it look like that was the error in sending actions.

Cyber, arsonist can not douse and light in the same night, its an either/or. So your scenario is wrong.

If Phil is a vig, he can just shoot Zambi tonight for safe keeping.


Stars, just stop talking, you......you aren't good at things.