Beginner Mafia Game #1

[phil.™]

Just curiosity pass, who were you protecting night 1?

[Passarelli]

You of course! I knew one of us was going to die. Either me for pointing out Fallen or you for hammering him.

[phil.™]

Bandwagon someone. I dont feel comfortable with mafia going into the night without us lynching anyone.
Best case scenario, we lynch a mafia tonight. Hopefully there is a cop or sheriff, and they target scum by chance. Day 2, he outs himself and out's scum. Bam, win for town.

But that's best case scenario, and wishful thinking lol.

Lol, i called it hahaha.

You of course! I knew one of us was going to die. Either me for pointing out Fallen or you for hammering him.

I had a good feeling you were doc.

[Passarelli]

I was way too active. I need to take a page out of scribble's book when I play doctor.

Minjae, did you lynch me because I picked out fallen?

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

All I have time to say is that pass was right.

You guys have to understand that no lynching is not always bad and is sometimes the only key left to winning a game as town.

[BladeTwinSwords]

The problem with having a Cop and Doctor but no Mafia Roles is that all the Doctor has to do is protect the Cop and stay hidden until the Cop learns who all the Mafia are.

[Nemesis]

A few notes,

This game was suppose to get you to talk, not be decided by some bullshit deadline or crappy modding. Assassin whined way too much.
Pass you're right, you played way too loud as a doctor.
Mafia segregated yourselves a bit too much, fallen, when accused you should have tried to make someone else look like the target rather than just say "it's not me" Doing so would have possibly changed you getting lynched.
Blade, they had no idea if there was a cop so Phil couldn't out himself confidently.
Pass, your "notes" were fucking stupid, never post that again.


All in all it wasn't too bad, but you guys need to maybe play a little more loose? Don't worry about throwing votes out. It took a little long to get anyone voting but that's not bad, the fact that there was discussion was the main focus.

So, who would be up to playing again, different set up though, maybe a few more people?

[phil.™]

Yeah, i'm down for another beginner game. Little bit more players, little bit more roles.

[Nemesis]

Yeah, i'm down for another beginner game. Little bit more players, little bit more roles.

Ya that's what i was thinking, with a few of the less pushy regs involved and a few more roles, but still a nice beginner friendly game.

[Passarelli]

I'd be up for another game.