Quote Originally Posted by CYBER View Post
1- ok, here's a few things that are confusing me nemesis.
Now you seem to claim that you're the best player among us (Tom seems to have agreed with this last game, but wtvr).
Last game you said that NO LYNCHING is the worst thing a townie can do because it it loses it's best weapon.
and not there you are telling the exact opposite? Or am i not understanding this correctly?
So yeay or nay on the NO LYNCH votes?
No but seriously, i dont fucking get it with ur post, it's like begging to say " Hey people! make sure you trust me! im the better player so u have to trust me with your lives even when i'm contradicting myself!"...
I'll have to pm tom about smthn first and update my vote if needed...
Ok, so here we can see Cyber breaking the first rule of Mafia, which is don’t get caught lying. I went through every comment in the last thread and no where do I even come close to saying that NO LYNCH is a bad idea. I’m the one who, after the rule is confirmed, starts with the NO LYNCH vote.
Rule of thumb in Mafia: Lynch the liars.
Quote Originally Posted by What View Post
Nemesis what the fuck are you talking about, you know that voting no lynch is the stupidest fucking thing the town can do, since on day 2 guess what your in the same god damn boat as day 1, no real information and your down a man who the mafia kill. Like Cyber said, last game you realized how stupid voting no lynch was and now you advocating it, which means either you just went full retard or you are trying to pull some shit.
See, this is where I start to run into trouble with this game. I can’t tell if what is trying to cover for the mafia, or too stupid to know how the game works, so I’m gonna take the approach that e’s stupid.
Day One: None of the investigative roles have had the chance to use any of their abilities, therefore we have no information as of yet. No one has said anything so any votes cannot be based on reasonable suspicion yet. Mafia games are set up with more townies than anything, so if you take a random shot in the dark the chance of hitting the “good guys” is higher. If this is done you’ve now hurt your chance to get as valuable information on in the night, because you’ve either a) killed an investigator b)killed a doctor, causing the investigator to not want to reveal information as he will die that night c) kill a valuable role for no reason.
Now, if you lynch a Mafia or evil role the first night? You’re golden, but how can you be sure? That is the problem with your random lynch.
Quote Originally Posted by What View Post
Now with what we do have: Nemesis's comments, when he confirmed he expressed his delight that whatever role he had could cause some really confusion or problems, now he is trying to subtly bait us into lynching him by supporting an option that he recognizes as being against the Town's best interests.
Here we have What lying as well. If you’ll notice I did not express “delight that whatever role he had could cause some really confusion or problems” I stated I was happy that this game had so many people, which would be more confusing. I ALSO STATED THIS BEFORE I GOT MY ROLE. You’ll see I confirm later on. You’ll also note that on my public wall Tom said he couldn’t send my role to me as my inbox was full. At the time of the post What is talking about, I had no role yet.

Quote Originally Posted by CYBER View Post
i think nemesis has smthn to hide but cant state it out loud for some reason. At first i thought he could be a mafia wanting a no lynch... but the way he made it obvious, it makes me think he was hinting smthn at us? perhaps a cop/killer wanting a no-lynch in order to carry out an investigation or kill during the night...
That intentional misjudgement, it makes me think that he's antagonizing people. Brett says it's a lynch-suicide? I dont believe so.
i think it has more to do with his night job, or else he'd be going all over the place defending his no-lynch idea. this somehow makes me believe he might actually be someone worth protecting, (i never though i'd ever say that! ENOUGH SAID.)
Can I point of the flaw in your first post? If I was a killer, would I not want people to get lynched? Would it not save me a turn in doing it myself? A serial killer would support the lynch of anyone in the game because it’s one step closer to winning and keeps the target off their back. Anyone who is eager to lynch is usually mafia or neutral.
Quote Originally Posted by What View Post
With Rape, well I'm really suspicious of anyone who is still advocating no lynch. IT DOES NOT WORK. Day 2 will come, we will be down a person and not know anything more than what we started with. It is an illogical and foolish choice to make.
How is being down one person worse than being down two? How does that add up? How does lynching one townie during the day then letting one die at night IMPROVE your odds? You have to be lying, there’s no way you are actually that stupid.

What we have here are two people who, without coming out and saying it, totally support each other. They have also both clearly lied in this game. I’m not saying lynch them, but the choice is yours.
As an aside – I’m having fun! Good job everyone!