Quote Originally Posted by What View Post
Thats a bad idea, cause now you are making yourself a target for the mafia since they will know you are not protected, and like i said, if nem is mafia, wasting two abilities on him is a terrible idea.

And what if you are lying? then Nem can't confirm it and you can persuade us to lynch him.

true.
but mafia will try to kill one of us nway right?

so by u guys picking 3 random ppl, i have no choice in the matter.
i will pick one of those ppl to confirm im a townie.

the doc can protect me, or one of the 3 or none at all.
mafia killing me serves them no purposes. i claimed i have no dangerous night ability. if i died, in fact, it would only prove me innocent townie, which is the whole point of this.

in fact, they might try to get to 1 of my 3 ppl, and they'd have to gamble on who they kill.
and if they killed the person i was trying to convey a msg to, then u can lynch me and prove ur point.
actually? ideally u'd wanna lynch scribble ( sry man, just using logic here) because he confirmed me, and if he's a townie then im 100% townie no questions asked.

another possibility is that i get roleblocked today by mafia, making me look horribly bad tomorrow. a cop can clear me, but if he/she doesnt wanna waste their ability on me, then i guess i'll be targetted for a lynch-wagon tomorrow... but again,,,, lynching me tomorrow would still leave the town with no confirmed townie, whereas lynching scribbs (again man, im rly rly sry, but u're the only who knows my honest intentions) then i'd be confirmed townie if he's a townie...

if he ISNT a townie, then woohoo for town bcos u guys got a mafia early in game, and ur horns will turn to me for a second mafia kill and gg if there's only 2 mafia.


if my reasoning is flaw'd correct me. but this is what im thinking about tonight...
im not saying im important to town, im actually quite expendable and willing to get policy lynched if town has no gd targets, but considering we have nthn to go on, it's my opinion that my plan above is a genuinely gd alternative to doing nthn.

thoughts?