Supernatural Mafia

[Old Bastard]

So what, we wait another 24 hrs for a replacement to get in, and most likely end up doing the same thing unless that person is a seasoned vet.

[SCRIBBLE]

I am not waiting on a replacement. Eight pages for the first day according to my post per page count and that is likely to make it to ten before we see a replacement. Then we continue to shit on the smallest things we find suspicious until we make some ridiculous, half-random vote anyways. We all ask for evidence and we all question the evidence given. Fun stuff these first days of mafia games.

[CYBER]

most likely my only post for today unless i browse on phone. but should be big enough for y'all. Bcos i couldn't give a rat's ass if you complain about my posts :P

for the record, blade's post number 83 was EDITED.... but i check'd the edit history, he only added the last line, as a fucking regular reply... pay attention blade.

Maybe sin is claiming vt as a scapegoat. To cover himself because he actually has a useful power role.

Except that Rufus wasn't a main role in the series, and assuming flavor is important, the odds of him having a role here are slim, ESPECIALLY when there are SOOOO many other "power characters" in the series that could easily have a power here.... and Sin fake claiming Rufus, even as a power role, is quite a dangerous move unless he IS in fact Rufus...

The problem that you guys don't get, and nem and brett seem to understand from the start, is that:
SURE mafia will NOT focus on a VT and he'll be safe... that's all dandy and shit, but:
- claiming VT while BEING a vt makes it so that mafia can narrow down the list of targets to hit more power roles.
- claiming VT while NOT BEING a vt, is a risky play depending on alias, AND can risk in town lynching that "useless" VT on day 1 to move along, but instead being surprised by hitting a power role...
- also blackmage covered the other points HERE.

So that's why it's an overall dumb thing to claim, especially if it became a mass movement... not saying sin is scummy or anything, but the play was questionable.

@passerelli

in pages 8 and 9:
I understand that you are definitely trying to tell people that "no lynching" on day 1 is bad, and there needs to be a lynch today. That's fine and all, you are right (imo) about the key points you posted, but you're leaving the hard part out for other ppl instead of yourself:
WHO. WHO do you want to lynch on day 1? see thats the hard question. people tend to the no lynch BECAUSE they can't point a finger at someone. and honestly, from experience, the only way we were able to isolate scummy behaviours is by waiting for bandwagons on a very random or stupid person and see how it plays out...And currently? that's either Stan for being irish 2.0, or nemesis... for, AGAIN, always pressing ppl buttons for claiming, yet dodges everything thrown at him.

Just letting you know Castiel was mostly the good guy, so your suspicions on him are dead Wrong. He is most likely a Doctor if anything.

most likely. but i could also see him more as a "Faith Healer"

finally,

@nemesis.

Here's a question for you.
You have pushed for lynching a "claimed" VT, knowing that you wont be hitting a power role, fine, but that's STILL a 100% town kill assuming that sin in fact could not have fake claimed this. So why would you still go after a "claimed" vt instead of doing your usual of pushing more buttons on other ppl at the time, to try to see if you can find someone MORE APPROPRIATE to lynch, that a town vt as day 1... it's like you simply locked in on getting anyone or anything lynched, instead of testing the waters with something else...

And then comes stan, stan goes afk, people start raging on it, nemesis clearly sees the opportunity of the irish 2.0, and then suddenly, when 2 votes were on stan, and 2 on you, you decide to let go of ur original decision to lynch sin as a "safe pick NON POWER ROLE VT" to vote on STAN, who MIGHT be a power role for town... even though his enthusiasm shows he might as well be another VT considering he was willing to get himself lynched in his deleted post without fear or breaking the game.

so again, i ask you nem, why are you pushing for a guaranteed town lynch? or do you just want anyone OTHER than yourself to get lynched on day 1 so that you go on your merry way for night 1?

FOS nemesis, until he starts answering why those constant aggressive plays on townies instead of looking into who is BUSSING those "almost 90%" townies to be lynched...you know... other than nemesis himself.

[phil.™]

Sorry stan, if you are going to be in, you should have stayed active. My vote is to stan, but i won't make it an official vote yet, as I do want to see if we could get a replacement for him. I am with scribbs though, I do not feel like waiting a full 24 hours.
Wolf, care to join again? lol

Side note, i have NO freaking idea where else I am logged in from. Home laptop and desktop browsers were off, work laptop and both work desktop is off, yet i'm still logged in (viewing under incognito).

[BladeTwinSwords]

for the record, blade's post number 83 was EDITED.... but i check'd the edit history, he only added the last line, as a fucking regular reply... pay attention blade.

I forgot how to forums, screw you lol.

[Old Bastard]

Last edited by BladeTwinSwords; Today at 12:10 PM. Reason: Because Cyber Sucks Dicks

I lol'd at that. Did that really seem like a good reason?

[BladeTwinSwords]

I lol'd at that. Did that really seem like a good reason?

It was a very good reason. Sucking dicks was how Cyber got his Visa.

[CYBER]

Sorry stan, if we could get a replacement for him. I am with scribbs though, I do not feel like waiting a full 24 hours.

If I remember correctly. What had a replacement ready in case someone fucked up.
And that person was either Tom or Wolf. But i'm betting tom would be the more seriously choice. bcos wolf is wolf.

[brett friggin favre]

If I remember correctly. What had a replacement ready in case someone fucked up.
And that person was either Tom or Wolf. But i'm betting tom would be the more seriously choice. bcos wolf is wolf.

And if it is Tom, there are better options for who we can lynch

[What]

Game Paused until further notice: at least 1 hour.