Nice bait, Nemesis. You'll eventually catch them!
4) Use admin privileges sparingly and appropriately.
Pass, sin: what you said regarding last person possibly being mafia and not wanting to seem suspicious is a great way to push suspicion on the last few people and draw another townie into voting to avoid that suspicion. Also a good thing to say to throw suspicion of mafia off yourself. The fact that you two together, having already been on that radar for other reasons, are putting that out there is concerning.
I want to go back to the fruit thing. We all know with a night start mafia are able to talk and typically come up with contingency plans for if/that scenarios. Sin throwing that fruit thing out there could have been some type of code after rod and other ideas were mentioned. Contingency plans are offen triggered during the day phase with some convoluted scheme. I do not necessarily think this is the case but definitely worth considering instead of wagoning someone. Take mind that there was no info, then after rod was debated suddenly three people have info. Once again I have to ask why wait to mention that when receiving a fruit or dealing a fruit is from what you claim such a harmless thing? Both pass and stars can confirm the fruit and that sin is not rod? They both targeted sin and are so freely willing to put that info out there?
Other questions that come to mind based off meta:
Why is Brett so silent?
Why is stars so aggressive?
Cyber is being cyber but lynching him might not provide that much info so why not lynch sin to figure out what he is?
Pass claims he will laugh at us if he is lynched... Way to soft an important role day one.
What is doing exactly what he did last game and is a hard read. In reality we could lynch anyone but based off the flavor and what people have claimed sin, stars, or pass would be the ones we would gain the most info from whether the outcome hurt or benefited town. It is a risk I personally would be willing to take, knowing full well they could be town. One sacrifice to truly verify two others where voting cyber would be a crap shoot.
Rushed type this out and will be on later to address other things.
- - - Updated - - -
After typing that out and seeing how long the post is, I feel like cyber. Someone mercy kill me, please.
Nemesis is not even bothering with game. Forgot to mention him.
I think reason is starting to crack through. Again and again you guys are trying to get people to do what you want by insinuating nearly any action they have is scummy. Lets take the vote train, Pass, you feel that since Cyber has not been hammered since the mafia don't want him to die. There are 5 people who were not on that train, thats a lot of Mafia. Sin says that this also shows the mafia is holding off, or is already on board, well that narrows it down doesn't it? That whole thing proves my point that trains garner little actual information other than allowing people to literally use the results to prove or argue anything they want.
No solid info, means we should treat the lynch as a tool to do that, and like Scribble said, its worth the gamble on a townie since numbers are on our side and it provides actionable information that makes the night and the following day much easier. As I said before, there is a method to my madness, as I showed last game and many times before. This is not a game of individuals, its a team game. If you're town and you die, but town wins, you win. That is the methodology I have been working with and you should too. Pass or Sin gives the most information, clearly I am leaning towards Pass. Stars has been very aggressive this game without providing a reason why, just wanting people to go with it. That is curious, but I do not see his death being as fruitful as the other two mentioned.
I hit Brett right in the feels.