all in all there is no where in the rules stating you can mute a player for having a "girly" voice.

dennis i would typically agree with you (you know how i am about people disrespecting admins) But if everyone who has posted actually posted something constructive for his case instead of insulting him for his voice and age he wouldnt have gotten pissed and deafened himself the way he did.

the mute is not justifiable
there is no demo of him spamming and his story has not changed
stop flaming or contribute to one of the sides, his or the accusing.