Supernatural Mafia

[kionay]

I already gave a comprehensive list, kionay. Read. Being lazy is NOT an excuse, and is viewed as a scum tactic.

being lazy is a scum tactic? how in the actual fuck is (witholding posts notwithstanding) being lazy seen as scummy? that... that's a thing? really?
alright, i'll look for your damn list >_<




...


Did I miss someone?

yeah, mikey? don't think he's claimed? but then again.. 75 pages, i could very easily be missing something

- - - Updated - - -

GODDAMNIT blackmage posts before i do FFFFUUUU


thank you black mage

[Sin]

Yes, stating you're "too lazy" or "don't feel like reading through 24 pages" is scummy as fuck. If you're town YOU WANT TO KNOW WHAT THE FUCK IS GOING ON! If you're mafia, you don't really care unless your name is mentioned, hence being inactive is considered scummy as well.

[BladeTwinSwords]

Yes, stating you're "too lazy" or "don't feel like reading through 24 pages" is scummy as fuck. If you're town YOU WANT TO KNOW WHAT THE FUCK IS GOING ON! If you're mafia, you don't really care unless your name is mentioned, hence being inactive is considered scummy as well.

This basically. Look at the 2 most inactive people. They got lynched first. The point is to post enough so you don't look scummy but not too much so you become a target.

[SCRIBBLE]

Vote me

[Sin]

Like you Blade. And you've made 2 posts and still have yet to claim. Bout to switch my vooote!

[kionay]

Yes, stating you're "too lazy" or "don't feel like reading through 24 pages" is scummy as fuck. If you're town YOU WANT TO KNOW WHAT THE FUCK IS GOING ON! If you're mafia, you don't really care unless your name is mentioned, hence being inactive is considered scummy as well.

you take this game way too seriously, man :-/

i've been looking through the roles on Epimafia's little learn thing

we SO should have a Cthulu as a levithan XD

[BladeTwinSwords]

Like you Blade. And you've made 2 posts and still have yet to claim. Bout to switch my vooote!

You know what, fuck it. I'm Gordon Walker.

[Sin]

http://supernatural.wikia.com/wiki/Gordon_Walker

So you're mafia?

[BladeTwinSwords]

http://supernatural.wikia.com/wiki/Gordon_Walker

So you're mafia?

Third-Party

[phil.™]

You know what, fuck it. I'm Gordon Walker.


Third-Party

Welppp, I didn't see that one coming.

[BladeTwinSwords]

Welppp, I didn't see that one coming.

That's kind of the point of a Third-Party.

- - - Updated - - -

It's up to you all now if you wish to lynch me or have the mafia murder me.

[Sin]

If we lynch you, you might come back as a vampire. :O

[kionay]

If we lynch you, you might come back as a vampire. :O

or he already IS a vampire! BWUAAAA

[phil.™]

Chances are, blade is fake claiming.
Kionay, what are you? What is your role?

[Sin]

If he's fake claiming he's hurting town, if his claim is real he's hurting town. Either way he's evil, but it's good information to have.

- - - Updated - - -

And yeah Kionay, who the fuck are you?

[Passarelli]

Why would someone claim 3rd party? Aren't they usually sided with themselves and just as bad as scum?

[kionay]

Chances are, blade is fake claiming.
Kionay, what are you? What is your role?

how do you know he's fake claiming?
we were supposed to have a cop, right? phil did you find out he's mafia or something? we'd all love to know

[SCRIBBLE]

Vote me

[kionay]

If he's fake claiming he's hurting town, if his claim is real he's hurting town. Either way he's evil, but it's good information to have.

i suppose there's no two ways about this, kinda black and white

i mean either he lied earlier about being VT, or he lied just now about not?

would it be more... idk... profitable(?) to try to lynch someone more likely to be mafia then a third-party since it'll be easier for mafia to win with it containing more people?
unsure kionay is unsure.

- - - Updated - - -


And yeah Kionay, who the fuck are you?

i don't like telling people who i am

i know it's seen as scummy but it makes me feel naked


and scribble wanting to die, surely What wouldn't put in a.. what's that suicide role? a jester?

[phil.™]

I have no proof that he's fake claiming. It's just, what sin said, if you're 3rd party, that's something kinda ehh to claim.

Kion is very suspicious now.
Blade and kion. Kion, both sin and I asked what you were.

[BladeTwinSwords]

Why would someone claim 3rd party? Aren't they usually sided with themselves and just as bad as scum?

Depends. If they are something like a Serial Killer than it's entirely based upon who they kill. If it's Survivor, mostly pointless. Cult needs to be killed immediately. Same goes for the Inquisitor. For Jester you just need to find him.

[Sin]

Bottom line is 3rd party is never really good for town, unless they're Cthulu or something, but then we'd WANT mafia to kill them.

[Passarelli]

Who cares if blade is fake claiming. 3rd parties are almost always anti-town and which class do you think a vampire would be? >_> We should vote Blade. If he is mafia--or even 3rd party; Vampires seem like they'd fit cultist--that means that Scribbles also very likely is guilty as this looks like a ploy to take the heat off Scribbles and Phil. This would make sense if they were cult and started with 1 vampire (2 nights with phil, scribbles, and blade converted).

What kind of setup do you guys think it is? 2 mafia, 1 werewolf, 1 vampire (cultist) and 11 townies?

What other 3rd party class do you think he could fit under?

[kionay]

I have no proof that he's fake claiming. It's just, what sin said, if you're 3rd party, that's something kinda ehh to claim.

Kion is very suspicious now.
Blade and kion. Kion, both sin and I asked what you were.

ya i know, but i don't want to tell you, because i think you'll kill me, phil, you've seemed scummy for a while, but since i'm terribad at this game i don't usually say anything

im fine with lynching a 3rd party (or useless VT and i guess MAYBE a mafia??) scribble, but i don't think you have any right to demand to know who i am without claiming either

- - - Updated - - -


Who cares if blade is fake claiming. 3rd parties are almost always anti-town and which class do you think a vampire would be? >_> We should vote Blade. If he is mafia--or even 3rd party; Vampires seem like they'd fit cultist--that means that Scribbles also very likely is guilty as this looks like a ploy to take the heat off Scribbles and Phil. This would make sense if they were cult and started with 1 vampire (2 nights with phil, scribbles, and blade converted).

What kind of setup do you guys think it is? 2 mafia, 1 werewolf, 1 vampire (cultist) and 11 townies?

What other 3rd party class do you think he could fit under?

what kind of setup? i've only ever seen 1 other setup so fuck if i know, haha

[BladeTwinSwords]

All I know is, I'm fucked 6 Ways From Sunday either way. Third-Party is basically fucked regardless and almost never win.

[kionay]

All I know is, I'm fucked 6 Ways From Sunday either way. Third-Party is basically fucked regardless and almost never win.

so it's between blade who admits he's fucked, who we are almost 100% sure will kill or convert someone, or scribble who is lieing and begging to die n shit


this isn't the kind of choices i signed on fir XD

[acolyte_to_jippity]

Gordon? hmm, could be a third-party hunter. that would fucking suck.

so far i'm still suspicious of nem and sin. though i do agree with sin's plan.

[SCRIBBLE]

lynch me you chodes and you will know who mafia is. Game over.

- - - Updated - - -

Lynch me you mathematically retarded chodes, holy fuck simple numbers suggest half of what you are saying is BULLSHIT.

[BladeTwinSwords]

lynch me you chodes and you will know who mafia is. Game over.

- - - Updated - - -

Lynch me you mathematically retarded chodes, holy fuck simple numbers suggest half of what you are saying is BULLSHIT.

I'm going to NOT vote to lynch you just to spite you.

[Sin]

Lynching you tells us Nem is mafia. That's it.

[BladeTwinSwords]

Lynching you tells us Nem is mafia. That's it.

The one time where Nem is scummy and actually IS mafia.

[kionay]

Lynching you tells us Nem is mafia. That's it.

did i miss something? i feel like i'm missing something

how does that tell us nem is mafia? O.o

[SCRIBBLE]

It means he lied. I want out of this game, no more contributions from me.

[acolyte_to_jippity]

2 third parties, and 2 mafia? that could be the setup, eh?

[Sin]

You should've just used your ability for the good of town and guarded OB/Brett, instead of wasting it on Aco of all people. I would've at least guarded Cyber/Wolf if anything. What a waste.

[kionay]

You should've just used your ability for the good of town and guarded OB/Brett, instead of wasting it on Aco of all people. I would've at least guarded Cyber/Wolf if anything. What a waste.

be glad it wasn't someone as scrub as me being a bodyguard

might've given you a stroke XD

[BladeTwinSwords]

2 third parties, and 2 mafia? that could be the setup, eh?

That would make sense to me. Most of the town roles we've seen/claimed so far have been minor at best. Mafia probably has slightly more powerful roles like Godfather, Roleblocker, Role Cop, Encryptor or something else.

[SCRIBBLE]

No shit sin that is why I said it was a waste but hey I was just blowing smoke right?

[phil.™]

Damn it kion, what are you?

[kionay]

Damn it kion, what are you?

how about i claim after we lynch one of our two lemmings? (haha made myself chuckle)

[BladeTwinSwords]

how about i claim after we lynch one of our two lemmings? (haha made myself chuckle)

How about fuck no and we lynch you instead for being EXTREMELY scummy.

[kionay]

How about fuck no and we lynch you instead for being EXTREMELY scummy.

you don't get an opinion, you're fucked six ways to sunday (your words) for being third party, i know i'm not mafia, which you don't and the possibility of me being VT makes me less scummy then you

i support voting for 1.spite, and 2.moving this thing the fuck along. so let's get rid of the damn vampire

VOTE BladeTwinSwords

it's 5 and i'm off work, i hope to see a dead vampire when i get on my computer at home -_-

[Passarelli]

Scribble, if you do not want to play anymore, please see if What can replace you. People "not wanting to play" ruins this game. That is why you confirmed that you actually wanted to play. Sigh.

Vote BladeTwinSwords

Blade, since you haven't done anything to allay our fears, I'm guessing I was right that you are a 3rd party cultist which pretty much requires us to remove you. if blade is indeed a cultist, we should then move on to phil then Scribble. Assuming mafia has 2 people and our protectors miss the next 2 days, I'm pretty sure this will be unwinable for town. Does everyone think they are aligned? If so, I'd say Phil is the cult leader. We need to cut the head off the snake as soon as possible.

- - - Updated - - -

Vote BladeTwinSwords

Forgot to color my vote

- - - Updated - - -

Actually, I'm retarded. The named vampire is likely the leader, so yeah--we should get rid of blade.

[BladeTwinSwords]

Definitely not a Cultist. That's an asshole role.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Heres my take. We pretty much know by this poiint that blade needs to be lynched, however... where does that lead us for D4 if we lynch blade now? We can confirm that he dosnt have a killing power, if he has a power at all. We would see multiple kills each night. (this is ofc assuming the mafia has a kill ability)

On the other hand, Scribble never fully claimed and has been beating around the bush. He is asking to be lynched. What we can gain from lynching scribbles first is a confirmation on whether or not nem lied apparently (according to scribbs). If scribbs turns up to be mafia, we can pretty much conclude that phil was in fact in cahoots with him.

I guess my point is, if we lynch blade today, we are back to another blind attempt at lynching baddies on D4. If we risk lynching scribble now, we can have blade to lynch tmrw and know of a second we need to dispatch immediately.

Correct me if im wrong here?

- - - Updated - - -

wait, where did we confirm that blade was a vampire or cultist? Did i miss a post?

[BladeTwinSwords]

On another note, if I am in fact a Vampire, there is the small chance that I will end up mafia. Then you WOULD be screwed as the mafia would possibly get 2 kills. One for Night 3 and the other for Night 4 since you all would obviously lynch me Day 4.

[SCRIBBLE]

I did fully claim. Reading comprehension for the win Mikey.

Pass I have nothing else to contribute because you all love to waste time saying the same shit over and over and ignore actual evidence just because you are told to do so.

[acolyte_to_jippity]

you don't get an opinion, you're fucked six ways to sunday (your words) for being third party, i know i'm not mafia, which you don't and the possibility of me being VT makes me less scummy then you

i support voting for 1.spite, and 2.moving this thing the fuck along. so let's get rid of the damn vampire

VOTE BladeTwinSwords

it's 5 and i'm off work, i hope to see a dead vampire when i get on my computer at home -_-

i'm going to agree with Blade on this one. No, I don't trust him, but he is right about you claiming.

[Passarelli]

DJ, it all depends on what third party you think Blade is. If he is Cultist he would likely be the leader since he is a named vampire. If he is a serial killer, that means we likely have a cult instead of mafia (only 1 kill / night). If Blade claims a role rather then just his alignment, we might be able to take the less cautious root and go after Scribbles or Phil.

Do the math though. If he IS a cultist and we do not lynch him tonight, he would have himself plus 3 minions. With 2 mafia, that'd be 6 anti-town roles. By the time we killed them all off we would be way behind.

It all really depends on what you think the setup is.

[BladeTwinSwords]

2 Cultists at the start of a game would be very broken.

[phil.™]

Phil is not mafia.
Period.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

DJ, it all depends on what third party you think Blade is. If he is Cultist he would likely be the leader since he is a named vampire. If he is a serial killer, that means we likely have a cult instead of mafia (only 1 kill / night). If Blade claims a role rather then just his alignment, we might be able to take the less cautious root and go after Scribbles or Phil.

Do the math though. If he IS a cultist and we do not lynch him tonight, he would have himself plus 3 minions. With 2 mafia, that'd be 6 anti-town roles. By the time we killed them all off we would be way behind.

It all really depends on what you think the setup is.

hmmm good point

Blade, are you of the cultist variety?

[BladeTwinSwords]

hmmm good point

Blade, are you of the cultist variety?

Vampire. Simple as that. No powers at all.

[Passarelli]

I don't understand how that would work, seeing as you need a win condition. How would a 'nilla 3rd party work?

- - - Updated - - -

Autocrat maybe? Hmm.

[BladeTwinSwords]

Survivor. Simply put, if I survive, I win. Jester is also technically the same. He has no powers but wins if he gets lynched.

[SCRIBBLE]

Vote me then. Please lynch the most viable protective asset you have left and prove my point.

[phil.™]

Before you make some bs vote, it's pretty obvious scribbs and I are not scum. So let's look at those who keeps pushing scribb and me as scum. Pass and kion, who both have yet to claim.
Those are our 2 mafias, nem possibly as the 3rd.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Before you make some bs vote, it's pretty obvious scribbs and I are not scum. So let's look at those who keeps pushing scribb and me as scum. Pass and kion, who both have yet to claim.
Those are our 2 mafias, nem possibly as the 3rd.

Problem is... is that there is no 100% confirmation that what you are saying is truth. Its basically your word against whoever.

[phil.™]

Problem is... is that there is no 100% confirmation that what you are saying is truth. Its basically your word against whoever.

True. Vote kion? Vote pass? Vote blade?
Hmmmmm

[BladeTwinSwords]

Before you make some bs vote, it's pretty obvious scribbs and I are not scum. So let's look at those who keeps pushing scribb and me as scum. Pass and kion, who both have yet to claim.
Those are our 2 mafias, nem possibly as the 3rd.

So we would assume 2 Third-Party and 2-3 Mafia.

I would love to tell you Brett's powers (When he was Werewolf) but I was not informed of his powers. I would assume he was either a Survivor-esque style like me or he had some power but got mafia killed before he could use it.

As it stands, I will not vote until everyone cards have been played on the table. To be completely honest, I think scribbs is not scum. Why would he WANT people to lynch him. The only other POSSIBLE reason is he is Jester which is stupid.

I agree with phil in that at least kion or pass claim.

- - - Updated - - -

I've literally done all that I can. I wish you all the best of luck. If I do survive the Day and Night, then I am pretty sure I will get a good idea of who the mafia are.

[Passarelli]

Phil, I have a soft claim out there. Do you have one yet?

I love how you try to redirect the pressure away from Blade--we had pretty much stopped talking about you and Scribbles, other then if he is Cult then you and Scribbles are also likely cult. This seems more and more probable since you keep trying to direct people away from each other.

[BladeTwinSwords]

Phil, I have a soft claim out there. Do you have one yet?

I love how you try to redirect the pressure away from Blade--we had pretty much stopped talking about you and Scribbles, other then if he is Cult then you and Scribbles are also likely cult. This seems more and more probable since you keep trying to direct people away from each other.

Seriously though, there is no Cult. Cult is one of the most broken roles out there and with 2 Third-Party, it's just op and I would never want to play What's games again.

[phil.™]

What the fuck is a cult?
Again, pass you are dodging our question. What are you?

Scribs could actually be scum, as a bomb. Him mentioning to us to lynch him so he can prove us wrong could be a tactic for mafia. Let's not vote to fast yet.

- - - Updated - - -

Too fast*

[BladeTwinSwords]

What the fuck is a cult?
Again, pass you are dodging our question. What are you?

Scribs could actually be scum, as a bomb. Him mentioning to us to lynch him so he can prove us wrong could be a tactic for mafia. Let's not vote to fast yet.

- - - Updated - - -

Too fast*

Cult is a Third-Party role that has the night power to recruit a person to the Cult. If the Cult kills everyone off, they win. The only things that prevent them from recruiting are Protection (Nothing happens) or Godfather (Cult Leader dies and a Cultist is selected as the Cult Leader most of the time). Cult is stupid overpowered if not eliminated immediately and so there is no way in hell that there would be a Cultist and another Third-Party.

[phil.™]

Cult is a Third-Party role that has the night power to recruit a person to the Cult. If the Cult kills everyone off, they win. The only things that prevent them from recruiting are Protection (Nothing happens) or Godfather (Cult Leader dies and a Cultist is selected as the Cult Leader most of the time). Cult is stupid overpowered if not eliminated immediately and so there is no way in hell that there would be a Cultist and another Third-Party.

Thank you for that.

Now pass and kion, what are you?

[Passarelli]

Phil, why are you pushing me to tell you when you haven't given me any reason to trust you? Several people already know who I am. If one of them wants to reveal me, so be it--but I am not going to get pushed around by scum.

- - - Updated - - -

Err, not who, but what. I role claimed, not flavor.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Phil, by no means am i attempting to convey a side in the matter, nor defend myself or others, as well as attempting to pry your role or suggest you are evil with the following statement.

If you are in fact a townie, i highly suggest staying your hand atm. You sound desperate and are acting very similar to the way you were acting in the last game when the pressure was on.

[kionay]

fuck netflix for not having the 9th season of supernatural up yet (╯°□°）╯︵ ┻━┻


it's pretty obvious scribbs and I are not scum.

no it isn't, you're leaking scum, oozing with it

i believe blade and phil are mafia (and possibly scribble tho he may be bonkers)

phil seems to love to ask people who they are and what they are, obsessed maybe, me, pass

afraid to claim phil? can't imagine why you would poke us so hard and accuse so readily with your butt buddy blade if you weren't mafia
let's lynch one of 'em and get on with it

[BladeTwinSwords]

Demanding to have someone role claim can be a double edged sword. If they have a power role, they could be killed off by mafia. A claim is just that, a claim and nothing more until there is proof that it is true/false.



Day 1
Stan Dies (Deputy)

Night 1
Brett Dies (Werewolf 3rd-Party)

Day 2
Locust Dies (VT)
Cyber replaced by Wolf
OB replaced by Brett

Night 2
Brett Dies...again! (Faith Healer)

So far we have

Scrib - Scrib
Sin - Scrib
Nem - Scrib
Pass - Blade
kion - Blade

Not Voted:

Wolf
Mikey
Blackmage
phil
Aco
Blade

- - - Updated - - -

6 are needed to lynch.

[Wolfenstinger]

I don't think I've ever seen Phil so antsy before... Like he's actually trying to hide something in front of all of us...


Just gut feeling though. Don't mind the gut.

[Sin]

Pass is cleared in my mind. As I hinted at in an earlier post. Phil is looking fishier and fishier.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Pass is cleared in my mind. As I hinted at in an earlier post. Phil is looking fishier and fishier.
at what point does one become a tuna?

[kionay]

at what point does one become a tuna?

this gave me a chuckle, thank you

thank you to blade for the overview (perhaps forums aren't the best place for a game with so much to keep track of)

phil is 99% mafia in my mind, from how he's acting, and if blade didn't feel fucked already i'd probably vote phil before scribble (because of spite, of course, hehehe :smirk::smirk:)

[BladeTwinSwords]

I'm pretty sure I know what Pass's role is but not what side.

Like I said, not voting until everyone has said their fill.

[phil.™]

What part of I am not scum. Period. Do we not understand?
Again, you guys are being deceived, by who else, kion and pass.
Fine, kion and pass, don't claim. I could honestly care less.

What's goodie nem?

[acolyte_to_jippity]

What part of I am not scum. Period. Do we not understand?


the part where we're supposed to blindly trust you, just because you said "period."

[phil.™]

the part where we're supposed to blindly trust you, just because you said "period."

Lol

What's poppin sin

[Passarelli]

Phil, if you are so keen to get me to claim, why don't you claim first? As I said before, several people already know my role. Who knows yours besides you? The other scum?

Loki is less of a trickster then you.

[Wolfenstinger]

Phil never caught up with what Pass is? Oh god this'll be good... :popcorn:

[phil.™]

You would love for me to claim wouldn't you scum.

Scribbs, what it doooo.

[Passarelli]

Phil, you asked me to claim. I said I already had leaked out plenty of hints and that you haven't claimed. I then offered to claim if you would. Then you say that you won't claim because you think I am scum?

Just--your logic is horrible or you are scum. Put yourself in my position. I had already soft claimed. I said that I suspected you but I felt that getting rid of Blade was more important as he could be cult and that I wasn't sure about you. Now though--you try to railroad me but don't give out any information as to why people should trust you even though I said I would happily claim if you did? The best argument you've given as to why people should trust you has been, "I am not scum. Period."

I smell scum.

Unvote BladeTwinSwords

Vote Phil

[phil.™]

Blade claimed 3rd party. Either lynched or killed by mafia during the night, he's a dead player. My main focus was to see if I could get under someone's skin, to get more information, which I have failed to do.
I did however get under your skin with just stating the obvious. To see who wants to get rid of me.

- - - Updated - - -

Oh, if it says I'm online, I may have left my browser up at work.

[SCRIBBLE]

42 pages by my count. Who has unedited forum settings and what is your page count?

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

42 pages by my count. Who has unedited forum settings and what is your page count?

84 pages

[SCRIBBLE]

Fuck.

[Passarelli]

I love how you say that Phil, but if you really wanted to do that--see who wanted to get rid of you--why didn't you just wait till a couple more people voted for you? All it shows now is that you were full of shit.

[kionay]

What part of I am not scum. Period. Do we not understand?

what part of you are lying do we not understand?

we should be on night by now having lynched phil or blades

[SCRIBBLE]

You two (pass/kion) would not know an orange from a dog.

[acolyte_to_jippity]

yeah...

fuck this shit. phil, you're either scum, or tanking the game for town on purpose.

either way,
vote phil

its telling when the guy who claims to be 3rd party is being more helpful than someone who refuses to claim for town.

- - - Updated - - -


You two (pass/kion) would not know an orange from a dog.

is this you defending phil/arguing against his lynching?

i'd be more than happy if you could explain why. mostly because then we will have gained some sort of information.

[SCRIBBLE]

Nem is the sure thing and you are all going for less suspect players over trivial details. I am not defending phil, just calling everyone dense. This game is stupid because you have all turned it into and 80+ page clusterfuck.

[phil.™]

You guys are idiots. Just because I push someone to claim, yet they say they "hint" and "soft claim" and still avoid claiming, when I'm playing the same game as them; I'm the scum?
I've hinted so many times that I'm not scum.

So if it's a hard claim y'all looking from me, I'll claim up, but I better hear a fucking hard claim from pass and kion because I am playing the same exact game as them.

Is that what y'all want? A hard claim?
Priest, I expected more from you if you were VT...

[What]

Vote Count:
Nem: Scribble
Sin: Scribble
Scrib: Scribble
Kionay: Blade
Pass: Phil
Aco: Phil

[SCRIBBLE]

Three more.

[phil.™]

Before I claim up, let's remember when locust claimed up VT, I was hesitant and told everyone to hold up on the vote. When locust was lynched up, I was shocked as shit as I had a feeling he was not scum. Who's vote was up there? Pass.

I'm not even looking at Stan's lynch as he lynched for inactivity.

[SCRIBBLE]

Vote for me then Phil, just end this game you pieces of plywood.

[phil.™]

No, you're staying in this with me, as we are not scum.

Tired of this bypass and me look like scum.
I am Ed Zeddmore - VT

vote pass

Kion your next.

- - - Updated - - -

No, you're staying in this with me, as we are not scum.

Tired of this bypass and me look like scum.
I am Ed Zeddmore - VT

vote pass

Kion your next.

- - - Updated - - -

Sorry for double post, stupid iPhone.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

No, you're staying in this with me, as we are not scum.

Tired of this bypass and me look like scum.
I am Ed Zeddmore - VT

vote pass

Kion your next.

- - - Updated - - -

No, you're staying in this with me, as we are not scum.

Tired of this bypass and me look like scum.
I am Ed Zeddmore - VT

vote pass

Kion your next.

- - - Updated - - -

Sorry for double post, stupid iPhone.

how do you know scribbs is 100% townie? Did i miss a post where he was confirmed?

[phil.™]

I honestly don't know he's 100% not mafia. I really don't. But my reads are on kion, pass and possibly priest or nem.

- - - Updated - - -

Like I said, scribbs could be mafia, as bomb as well. Not willing to risk it.
Right now, we have facts. It was recent that I asked kion or pass to claim up, it's been a while now. They kept dodging it.

- - - Updated - - -

Does nem work late hours?

[SCRIBBLE]

Nem has avoided posting because he is grasping at straws and his best plan is to be silent.

[acolyte_to_jippity]

No, you're staying in this with me, as we are not scum.

Tired of this bypass and me look like scum.
I am Ed Zeddmore - VT

vote pass

Kion your next.

- - - Updated - - -

No, you're staying in this with me, as we are not scum.

Tired of this bypass and me look like scum.
I am Ed Zeddmore - VT

vote pass

Kion your next.

- - - Updated - - -

Sorry for double post, stupid iPhone.

thank you.

unvote phil
unvote phil
unvote phil
unvote phil
unvote phil

couldn't remember what the 'unvote' color was. figured i'd cover my bases.

- - - Updated - - -

wait, why would you be so hesitant to claim a VT phil? its not like it would make you a target. mafia knows who is not mafia. they would prefer to kill a power role, sure. but you claimed VT.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

time for bed will pick up in the morning.

[BladeTwinSwords]

I'm going to trust phil on this one.

That leaves kion.

Well, it's your move...

[phil.™]

I'm going to bed.
Just read my post. I was always VT side. Just "hinted" ffs. i hate that.

Pass, i am giving you 7am EST to hard claim. No more soft claim shit. We both soft claimed, now i've hard claimed. Kion, my eyes are on you. If pass hard claims, i will unvote and vote you.

[Passarelli]

Whelp, guess I owe you Phil.

Gabriel - double voter a.k.a. judge.

- - - Updated - - -

That said, I still think you are playing scummy.

[phil.™]

I play scummy, you never played with me in GG lol.
Kion, you're up.

You have until 7am EST

[BladeTwinSwords]

Whelp, guess I owe you Phil.

Gabriel - double voter a.k.a. judge.

- - - Updated - - -

That said, I still think you are playing scummy.

I was correct in my guess. You are the Double Voter.

[phil.™]

wait, why would you be so hesitant to claim a VT phil? its not like it would make you a target. mafia knows who is not mafia. they would prefer to kill a power role, sure. but you claimed VT.

Even claiming VT with no power role could be bad for town, as it narrows mafia's target. I was going to claim right after sin, since i am a nobody (hence my absence day 1). Claiming this late can also be bad town sided, but if it was a claim you guys wanted, i claimed up.

With that said, kion i gave you plenty of time, not just last night but the past few nights..
Unvote

Vote kion

[Sin]

Blackmage has been so fucking quiet. Wonder if he's the GodFather.

[kionay]

Right now, we have facts. It was recent that I asked kion or pass to claim up, it's been a while now. They kept dodging it.

i already gave you a very straightforward answer, i didn't want to claim, especially not beacuse someone who didn't claim (at the time) asked me, did you not read what i put?
what are these "facts" exactly? you keep throwing the word around like we're all supposed to trust you, and you kept dodging it too (until recently)


wait, why would you be so hesitant to claim a VT phil? its not like it would make you a target. mafia knows who is not mafia. they would prefer to kill a power role, sure. but you claimed VT.

he has a good point


Kion, you're up.

You have until 7am EST



With that said, kion i gave you plenty of time, not just last night but the past few nights..
Unvote

Vote kion

why do people find it so hard to type out the last 2 letters?

man i wasn't fucking aware that late last night, dafuq is your problem? like i have time to check this forum at 7 in the morning? really? i had to get to work (which i'm at now)
you want more information? fine. I'm Bobby Singer

ya damn idgit!


Blackmage has been so fucking quiet. Wonder if he's the GodFather.

that's uncertain, what's more certain is that phil is lying scum, let's think about lynching blackmage when we know more well if it's him and for now get rid of the scum that is RIGHT in front of us (phil and blade)

phil skipping by with these bullshit "facts" has gone on long enough

Unvote

Vote Phil

[Sin]

Bobby Singer... what? Are you the Cop? Who have you investigated the past 2 nights? Why haven't you brought any information to the table kionay?

[phil.™]

Pshhh scum written all over you. I hard claimed VT, told YOU many times i'm VT and helping town. If you vote lynch me, I can only assume you're scum.
What's your role scum?

- - - Updated - - -


Bobby Singer... what? Are you the Cop? Who have you investigated the past 2 nights? Why haven't you brought any information to the table kionay?

Cause he's not a cop, he fake claimed. He said a name and that's it.

[Sin]

We need a hard claim here kion. What's your role?

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Here is what I think, phil is scum as fuck, his behaviour these last 24 hours is identical to how he behaved last game when he tried ro claim out of a lynch. He ended up being mafia. He is hysterical and demanding claims from people (likley to find the cop) as if his shit dont stink like the rest of us. A VT claim is easy to fake with this show due tothe sheer volume of characters that are not main.

Pass, I thought you were better then that. To not be so easily manipulated. Think about amd reflect on everything that has transpired in the last 24 hours...

What some of you fail to understand is that claiming is just that... a claim. By no means does a claim exonerate someone from scrutiny and as far as im concerned the only person who is 100 percent confirmed is pass.

Kionay is the cop and iv figured that was the case for awhile now. Id like to think that the people he investigated are townies and thus his reluctancy to claim thus far.

[phil.™]

If he's cop, then kion, please let us know who you investigated the past 2 nights.

- - - Updated - - -

I am not scum. Getting people to start talking, correction, getting people who has put nothing on the table to start talking, I didn't think that was a scum move. As we are now up to 87 pages, maybe compiled only 10-15 useful stuff.
Mikey, you are starting to get suspicious to me as well. Did you claim yet? Or even "soft" claim?

[kionay]

Pshhh scum written all over you. I hard claimed VT, told YOU many times i'm VT and helping town. If you vote lynch me, I can only assume you're scum.

your a liar, you can "tell" us you're VT till you're blue in the face but that doesn't make it true, if we vote lynch you then we'll be down at least 1 mafia


If he's cop, then kion, please let us know who you investigated the past 2 nights.

- - - Updated - - -

I am not scum. Getting people to start talking, correction, getting people who has put nothing on the table to start talking, I didn't think that was a scum move. As we are now up to 87 pages, maybe compiled only 10-15 useful stuff.
Mikey, you are starting to get suspicious to me as well. Did you claim yet? Or even "soft" claim?

damn you poke the bear mikey and he gets pissy, someone remotely threatens him and he jumps on

why are we still even talking? phil needs to get lynched, it's like the mafia is running their ass in our face and we've collectively decided that's fine because phil has such a silk tounge? (sarcasm, please)

when the wild phil is backe into a corner it lashes out, CRIKEY!

[BladeTwinSwords]

I think just about everyone has had their fill. I'll make my decision by the end of today.

[phil.™]

No never lashing, it's just a game lol. I put emphasis to help, just a game. Still 1 community. With that said...

FUCK YOU, then lynch me. It will go something like...

Blah blah
More hidden flavour text
blah blah,
Ed Zeddmore is going here, need a hand
Ed Zeddmore (VT) was killed

THEN kion and mikey will look scummy as fuck.. As most probably already know I'm just a VT, nothing more. No power no nothing.
So go ahead, start the lynch, i'll take one for the town.

I have hard claimed. You two have yet to hard claim as well.
And kion, why havent you responded to the question "who did you investigate first 2 nights?"

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Phil you have clearly lost your senses.

Here is what we know, pass is confirmed townie. Blade admitted third party.
the rest is speculation. If your this determined perhaps we lynch blade and have the cop investigate the fuck out of you to clear the water.

[phil.™]

Phil you have clearly lost your senses.

Here is what we know, pass is confirmed townie. Blade admitted third party.
the rest is speculation. If your this determined perhaps we lynch blade and have the cop investigate the fuck out of you to clear the water.

I'm game. If you did say kion is cop, I would still like to know who he investigated N1 and N2.

[kionay]

... kion ...
...And kion ...

what is it about those last two letters that people hate so much?


Phil you have clearly lost your senses.

Here is what we know, pass is confirmed townie. Blade admitted third party.
the rest is speculation. If your this determined perhaps we lynch blade and have the cop investigate the fuck out of you to clear the water.

don't let phil's silk tounge give him another night, don't let phil harm anyone!

[Nemesis]

Here is what I think, phil is scum as fuck, his behaviour these last 24 hours is identical to how he behaved last game when he tried ro claim out of a lynch. He ended up being mafia. He is hysterical and demanding claims from people (likley to find the cop) as if his shit dont stink like the rest of us. A VT claim is easy to fake with this show due tothe sheer volume of characters that are not main.

Pass, I thought you were better then that. To not be so easily manipulated. Think about amd reflect on everything that has transpired in the last 24 hours...

What some of you fail to understand is that claiming is just that... a claim. By no means does a claim exonerate someone from scrutiny and as far as im concerned the only person who is 100 percent confirmed is pass.

Kionay is the cop and iv figured that was the case for awhile now. Id like to think that the people he investigated are townies and thus his reluctancy to claim thus far.

I agree, he mexican jumped all over the place to get all the attention away from Scrib and continues to throw as many people under the bus as possible.

By claiming VT we take no chances of lynching power role by lynching him but do have a chance to get mafia.

He is either playing terribly or is scum.

[phil.™]

Still refusing to say who he investigated...

- - - Updated - - -

To re-cap:

Sin: Rufus - VT
Cyber/Wolf: Dean - Hunter
Nem: Samuel - Jailer
Scribble: Sam - Bodyguard
Aco: Chuck - VT
Pass: Gabriel - Double Voter aka Judge
Phil: Ed Zeddmore - VT
Blade: Gordon Walker - 3rd Party

Kion: Nothing - Soft claim cop?
BM: Nothing
Mikey: Nothing

OB/Brett: Cass - Faith Healer *DEAD*
Stan: Garth - Deputy *DEAD*
Brett: Prof - Werewolf *DEAD*
Locust: Cain - VT *DEAD*

- - - Updated - - -

Is this list correct?

[Nemesis]

Still refusing to say who he investigated...

- - - Updated - - -

To re-cap:

Sin: Rufus - VT
Cyber/Wolf: Dean - Hunter
Nem: Samuel - Jailer
Scribble: Sam - Bodyguard
Aco: Chuck - VT
Pass: Gabriel - Double Voter aka Judge
Phil: Ed Zeddmore - VT
Blade: Gordon Walker - 3rd Party

Kion: Nothing - Soft claim cop?
BM: Nothing
Mikey: Nothing

OB/Brett: Cass - Faith Healer *DEAD*
Stan: Garth - Deputy *DEAD*
Brett: Prof - Werewolf *DEAD*
Locust: Cain - VT *DEAD*

- - - Updated - - -

Is this list correct?

No, since you and scribs are most likely lying.

[kionay]

No, since you and scribs are most likely lying.

this.


Phil i wouldn't go for a profession that requires you to lie, i don't think you'd do too well :-/

[Nemesis]

I still find it strange that scrib can actively lie and doesn't get the votes.

Townies have no reason to lie at all.

Scrib stating he protected Aco is a lie since he was roleblocked and would have been informed of such, save for shitty modding.

Scrib should be lynched for lying. Also, if he was a bodyguard his entire purpose would be to protect important players, letting the doc die is the scummiest thing he could do.

[Sin]

I still want to know WHO you investigated on both nights Kion. If you investigated Nem the first night, it would make sense why you would back him up so adamantly on Day 2 the way you did. Who did you investigate on Night 2?

The reason we need to know this is because I have a suspicion you're an Insane Cop, like I mentioned on Day 2.

The only reason to have a Deputy is if there is an insane cop, but we can use this to our advantage, Kionay.

WHO DID YOU INVESTIGATE AND WHAT WERE THE OUTCOMES?!

- - - Updated - - -



Scrib should be lynched for lying. Also, if he was a bodyguard his entire purpose would be to protect important players, letting the doc die is the scummiest thing he could do.

I agree, which is why my vote is still on Scribs. His excuse for doing so was stupid as well. Calling it a "waste" isn't a reason. If you were bodyguard you should have used your action on Brett, like I've said.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Nem n1 brett n2. Its pretty obvious

[kionay]

I still want to know WHO you investigated on both nights Kion. If you investigated Nem the first night, it would make sense why you would back him up so adamantly on Day 2 the way you did. Who did you investigate on Night 2?

The reason we need to know this is because I have a suspicion you're an Insane Cop, like I mentioned on Day 2.

The only reason to have a Deputy is if there is an insane cop, but we can use this to our advantage, Kionay.

WHO DID YOU INVESTIGATE AND WHAT WERE THE OUTCOMES?!


still don't get why 'ay' is so painful to type, maybe it's just spite at this point?

also i thought the deputy was just like a sherrif? on epic mafia's help thingy (which i basically have to have up all the time now) it doesn't say anything about a relation with a cop, is there another version?

[Sin]

WHY WOULD YOU WASTE AN INVESTIGATION ON FUCKING BRETT/OB!?!?!?!?!?

And Mikey, let the nigger speak for himself. Is your role "the voice of the cop" or some shit?

- - - Updated - - -

Mafiascum... epicmafias roles are retarded. Mafiascum is what we go off of, or should go off of at least.

- - - Updated - - -

Tell us who you investigated and what you found out, for christs sake everyone already knows your the cop so you're dead come Night 3 anyway. We need to figure out if you're insane or not.

[SCRIBBLE]

boring.Vote me already.

[kionay]

you're dead come Night 3 anyway. We need to figure out if you're insane or not.

that's not staying optimistic :( i wanted to live, but if the only way to lynch phil is to tell you who i investigated is then fine, it was nem first night (innocent) and sin the second night (innocent)

i thought someone said you could figure out if you were insane by investigating someone who's dead, so i asked what, apparently you can't

http://img1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20131224233033/prettylittleliars/images/f/fb/The_more_you_know_banner.jpg

yaya go ahead and cry about how i'm bad at this game, i know i am

now, let's get phil lynched this time, scribble/blade the two days after that and boom victory, isn't it wonderful

gogogo

- - - Updated - - -

asked What* the person, not the pronoun

- - - Updated - - -


boring.Vote me already.

wait your turn -_-

[SCRIBBLE]

No way nem is innocent so kionay is definitely lying. just lynch me and the point will be proven and town can win.

- - - Updated - - -

Lynch me then if nem is innocent. If nem is innocent according to kion then I am scum so lynch me and prove it.

- - - Updated - - -

Or nem is godfather and kion is stupid.

[phil.™]

but if the only way to lynch phil is to tell you who i investigated is then fine

now, let's get phil lynched this time, scribble/blade the two days after that and boom victory, isn't it wonderful

gogogo


I was never eager to lynch you, i was only eager to know what you were, and who you investigated, as you kept dodging the question.
You being this eager to get me lynched is quite unsettling..

[kionay]

I was never eager to lynch you, i was only eager to know what you were, and who you investigated, as you kept dodging the question.
You being this eager to get me lynched is quite unsettling..

ya coz you're scum

funny how you quieted down when you realized i didn't investigate you huh?

you've been acting scumy as fuck and now you want to survive the day to kill me at night

[phil.™]

funny how you quieted down when you realized i didn't investigate you huh?

I stayed quiet because I was replacing two tires.

[kionay]

I stayed quiet because I was replacing two tires.

quieted as in stopped bereting people with questions and accusing everyone in sight

you're acting all nice and quiet now to try to make it to night to kill me no doubt

don't make excuses, just get lynched

[Sin]

Nem could still possibly be godfather, and therefore his previous claim is bullshit and we never had 3 protective roles.

We now know Kionay is NOT an insane cop though, as he's confirmed me. Still skeptical about Nem, even moreso now. He kept bringing up the Godfather role multiple times this game.

I'm going to pullback my vote on Scrib. If Nem IS the Godfather he's harmless at Night, so we should be focusing someone else that's been scummy.

Mikey and Blackmage need to claim now. We need to protect Kionay on Night 3, and we also need to know if there is a "fourth" protection type role in play.

And honestly, Scribble, should be replaced if he doesn't want to play the game anymore. I was feeling the same way, but now that new information has come up I'm excited again.

- - - Updated - - -

UNVOTE SCRIBBLE

[phil.™]

quieted as in stopped bereting people with questions and accusing everyone in sight

you're acting all nice and quiet now to try to make it to night to kill me no doubt

don't make excuses, just get lynched

No, i stayed quiet because pass claimed, you claimed and was confirmed by Sin. That is all I asked since last night. For you two to claim up.
My vote is still up for you because, well, you seem scummy as shit honestly.

[kionay]

Nem could still possibly be godfather, and therefore his previous claim is bullshit and we never had 3 protective roles.

We now know Kionay is NOT an insane cop though, as he's confirmed me. Still skeptical about Nem, even moreso now. He kept bringing up the Godfather role multiple times this game.

I'm going to pullback my vote on Scrib. If Nem IS the Godfather he's harmless at Night, so we should be focusing someone else that's been scummy.

Mikey and Blackmage need to claim now. We need to protect Kionay on Night 3, and we also need to know if there is a "fourth" protection type role in play.

And honestly, Scribble, should be replaced if he doesn't want to play the game anymore. I was feeling the same way, but now that new information has come up I'm excited again.

- - - Updated - - -

UNVOTE SCRIBBLE

well to be 100% fair you could be godfather and nem town

either way who we need to lynch is pretty clear (and unless you're missing a hemisphere of your brain you know who i mean)

[Nemesis]

Nem could still possibly be godfather, and therefore his previous claim is bullshit and we never had 3 protective roles.

We now know Kionay is NOT an insane cop though, as he's confirmed me. Still skeptical about Nem, even moreso now. He kept bringing up the Godfather role multiple times this game.

I'm going to pullback my vote on Scrib. If Nem IS the Godfather he's harmless at Night, so we should be focusing someone else that's been scummy.

Mikey and Blackmage need to claim now. We need to protect Kionay on Night 3, and we also need to know if there is a "fourth" protection type role in play.

And honestly, Scribble, should be replaced if he doesn't want to play the game anymore. I was feeling the same way, but now that new information has come up I'm excited again.

- - - Updated - - -

UNVOTE SCRIBBLE

You're not cleared at all. For the exact reasons I've been stating the whole time. It's still you Scrib and Phil.

[kionay]

No, i stayed quiet because pass claimed, you claimed and was confirmed by Sin. That is all I asked since last night. For you two to claim up.
My vote is still up for you because, well, you seem scummy as shit honestly.

ya the cop is scummy to you only because you don't want to get lynched

even with people claiming you bereted people and pointed fingers

AND if you were VT you wouldn't know if those claims were true or not, but you seem pretty confident that you have all the information you need to know who you're gonna kill night 3

[Sin]

Also Phil, pushing for a lynch on a claimed cop is super scummy. Unvote until Blackmage claims.

Mikey's obviously not the cop because he thinks Kionay investigated Brett, which would have been an idiotic move in the first place.

Mikey are you VT as well? Tell us.

- - - Updated - - -


You're not cleared at all. For the exact reasons I've been stating the whole time. It's still you Scrib and Phil.

If I was scum why would I be telling everyone to Protect Kionay on Night 3? That would go against what I would want as a mafia member. You overlooking that is weird as fuck Nem, even for you.

I'm starting to believe Scribs claims now as well, and I fucking HOPE blackmage is a protective role, because you will be dead today Nemesis. Bullshit claim, I always suspected Roleblocker to be a mafia role anyway.

[Nemesis]

Also Phil, pushing for a lynch on a claimed cop is super scummy. Unvote until Blackmage claims.

Mikey's obviously not the cop because he thinks Kionay investigated Brett, which would have been an idiotic move in the first place.

Mikey are you VT as well? Tell us.

- - - Updated - - -



If I was scum why would I be telling everyone to Protect Kionay on Night 3? That would go against what I would want as a mafia member. You overlooking that is weird as fuck Nem, even for you.

I'm starting to believe Scribs claims now as well, and I fucking HOPE blackmage is a protective role, because you will be dead today Nemesis. Bullshit claim, I always suspected Roleblocker to be a mafia role anyway.

Three reasons:

1. There's a good chance we have no protective roles left, so you saying it is lip service. We all know I can't protect him since he can't use his abilities if I do.
2. It's common fucking sense that anyone who could would protect him you twat, you have no need to point it out at fucking all other than to say, "Hey! Remember me? I'm a good guy. Everyone look!"
3. I have not been informed of you receiving any substantial brain damage.

[phil.™]

Unvote

[SCRIBBLE]

It is not that I want to quit the game but I know my death would prove several things that would allow town to win.

[Sin]

Three reasons:

1. There's a good chance we have no protective roles left, so you saying it is lip service. We all know I can't protect him since he can't use his abilities if I do.
2. It's common fucking sense that anyone who could would protect him you twat, you have no need to point it out at fucking all other than to say, "Hey! Remember me? I'm a good guy. Everyone look!"
3. I have not been informed of you receiving any substantial brain damage.

It isn't fucking common sense considering OUR DOC IS DEAD! And either your or scribs could have protected him. Incoming, "well if I protected him I would have stopped him from protecting someone else deerp herpes."

Like I said, we need to hear from Blackmage and Mikey. Full claims.

[Nemesis]

It isn't fucking common sense considering OUR DOC IS DEAD! And either your or scribs could have protected him. Incoming, "well if I protected him I would have stopped him from protecting someone else deerp herpes."

Like I said, we need to hear from Blackmage and Mikey. Full claims.

Bullshit, all that does it out any remaining power roles for you to pick off. Fuck That.

[BladeTwinSwords]

I honestly believe that we should lynch whoever will give us the most information.

[Sin]

It's my word against yours Nem. Since the beginning of the game, and you've been the scummiest player the entire game.

If we lynch Scribble this is how it will go:

- Scribble is dead and confirmed as Bodyguard Townie
- Proving Nem was lying and mafia aligned
- Kionay will die Night 3

If we lynch Phil:

- Phil is dead and confirmed VT
- Kionay will die Night 3

If we lynch Sin:

- Sin is dead and confirmed VT
- Proving Nem is the Godfather as he came up innocent
- Scribs (if Townie Bodyguard) could protect Kionay
- Kionay investigates Blackmage/Mikey/Aco/Phil

If we lynch Nem:

- Nem is dead and confirmed Townie Roleblocker
- Proving Scribs is bullshitting and couldn't even protect Aco as he stated
- Kionay dies Night 3

All in all, I believe lynching me would yield the best results, IF one of you faggots protects Kionay.

[Nemesis]

I honestly believe that we should lynch whoever will give us the most information.

You're right.

Vote What

TELL US EVERYTHING

- - - Updated - - -


It's my word against yours Nem. Since the beginning of the game, and you've been the scummiest player the entire game.

If we lynch Scribble this is how it will go:

- Scribble is dead and confirmed as Bodyguard Townie
- Proving Nem was lying and mafia aligned
- Kionay will die Night 3

If we lynch Phil:

- Phil is dead and confirmed VT
- Kionay will die Night 3

If we lynch Sin:

- Sin is dead and confirmed VT
- Proving Nem is the Godfather as he came up innocent
- Scribs (if Townie Bodyguard) could protect Kionay
- Kionay investigates Blackmage/Mikey/Aco/Phil

If we lynch Nem:

- Nem is dead and confirmed Townie Roleblocker
- Proving Scribs is bullshitting and couldn't even protect Aco as he stated
- Kionay dies Night 3

All in all, I believe lynching me would yield the best results, IF one of you faggots protects Kionay.

lol by that logic isn't it best to lynch you?

[Sin]

I just said that, idiot.

[Nemesis]

I just said that, idiot.

Yes, and that's funny, nigger-lips.

[Sin]

Find a flaw in that logic, cupcake?

[BladeTwinSwords]

Come on gang, only 5 more votes to lynch What!

[kionay]

the roleblock doctor bodyguard combo thing has me so goddamn confused as to what means what


how about someone who hasn't talked in a while claim? hmm?

[Sin]

I still want to hear from Blackmage and Mikey. Mikey, I know you're reading this.

What are you?

- - - Updated - - -

Faith Healer - Has a chance to protect someone from a Night kill
Jailer - Protects someone but also stops them from using abilities
Bodyguard - Protects someone by taking a bullet for them (getting them killed)

[kionay]

I still want to hear from Blackmage and Mikey. Mikey, I know you're reading this.

What are you?

- - - Updated - - -

Faith Healer - Has a chance to protect someone from a Night kill
Jailer - Protects someone but also stops them from using abilities
Bodyguard - Protects someone by taking a bullet for them (getting them killed)

ya i get what they do

but you're saying that beacuse of the past events these things have to be true, like if player a is this then player b is this because player c was this and this happened and this was all like 50 pages ago and i've completely lost track

[Sin]

Basically either Scribble or Nemesis are lying at this point, but since YOU investigated Nemesis and he turned up Town, it gives us something to go off of if I'm lynched, because it would prove that Nemesis is the Godfather having FOOLED you as the Cop and also that he was lying about Roleblocking Scribble.

[kionay]

Basically either Scribble or Nemesis are lying at this point, but since YOU investigated Nemesis and he turned up Town, it gives us something to go off of if I'm lynched, because it would prove that Nemesis is the Godfather having FOOLED you as the Cop and also that he was lying about Roleblocking Scribble.

ya i'm still not following how you're getting from point a to point b here

why is it either scribble or nem are lying at this point? what does it mean if you are? how would you being lynched 'prove' that nem is godfather?

- - - Updated - - -

how the fuck do you people keep TRACK of all dis shit?

[Blackmage]

Writing more in, just getting the requested part out of the way. Martin Creaser - VT.

[Sin]

ya i'm still not following how you're getting from point a to point b here

why is it either scribble or nem are lying at this point? what does it mean if you are? how would you being lynched 'prove' that nem is godfather?

- - - Updated - - -

how the fuck do you people keep TRACK of all dis shit?

Scribble stated he was Sam Winchester - Bodyguard.
He said he did not use his ability at all on Night 1.
He said he used his protection ability on Aco on Night 2.

Nem, contradicted him saying that he used his ability on Scribble, which would make Scribbles claim a lie as he would have received a message from the Mod that his ability did not work.

So either Nem or Scrib are lying.

[kionay]

Writing more in, just getting the requested part out of the way. Martin Creaser - VT.

heh the crazy guy

though he could be seen as a bit of a bad guy, taking a hostage to lure out and try to kill benny :-/

- - - Updated - - -


Scribble stated he was Sam Winchester - Bodyguard.
He said he did not use his ability at all on Night 1.
He said he used his protection ability on Aco on Night 2.

Nem, contradicted him saying that he used his ability on Scribble, which would make Scribbles claim a lie as he would have received a message from the Mod that his ability did not work.

So either Nem or Scrib are lying.

alright, with ya so far, now why does lynching you prove nem is godfather and lying? isn't there the remote possibility that he's VT but lied to try to out someone?

[Sin]

Because you investigated him and he came up Innocent.

Unless you're lying about investigating the both of us which would throw a wrench into the entire idea.

[kionay]

Because you investigated him and he came up Innocent.

Unless you're lying about investigating the both of us which would throw a wrench into the entire idea.

and why can't you both be innocent? just because he lied doesn't neccessarily mean he's mafia, right? (though lieing is scummy i understand of course)

[Sin]

Liars get lynched. Simple.

[phil.™]

I lied about doing tires this morning.. I was actually tinting the front 2 windows on a 2004 Ford Explorer. The back windows were already tinted so the customer just wanted the front 2 windows tinted to match the back. This may change some outcomes =\

[Wolfenstinger]

Honestly with the 2 nights that have passed already, there's a damn good chance that there is a godfather in play and that one of the VT claims are fake as well. But it also means that the mafia so far only have shown a kill a night. So.... yeah. Waitin on blackmage's texts because they are always interesting.

[phil.™]

ANDDDD, waiting on Mikey.

[Sin]

Yeah Mikey. WTF! Mikey is the new Phil. Pretending to be AFK while continuing to read the thread and not post.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Gwen Campbell - vt

Sorry, just got on my lunch break.

[phil.™]

So everyone claimed right?

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

So everyone claimed right?

Yes, however for the record .. for future games. This mass claiming thing is horrible. You out everyones roles and give the mafia exactly what they want. The mafia can now plan better on how they go about winning the game. Mass claiming ia rookie and I think we have enough enough intelligent people to play the game the way its meant to be played.

[phil.™]

Yes, i realize it is a horrible idea, but you also have to know, probably 2-3 people have lied. AKA mafia. Now we just have to see who falls in their own lie.

[kionay]

Yes, however for the record .. for future games. This mass claiming thing is horrible. You out everyones roles and give the mafia exactly what they want. The mafia can now plan better on how they go about winning the game. Mass claiming ia rookie and I think we have enough enough intelligent people to play the game the way its meant to be played.

your cop(me) is a scrub, so not neccessarily :(

[phil.™]

Sin: Rufus - VT
Cyber/Wolf: Dean - Hunter
Nem: Samuel - Jailer
Scribble: Sam - Bodyguard
Aco: Chuck - VT
Pass: Gabriel - Double Voter aka Judge
Phil: Ed Zeddmore - VT
Blade: Gordon Walker - 3rd Party
Kion: Bobby Singer - Cop
BM: Martin Creaser - VT
Mikey: Gwen Campbell - VT


OB/Brett: Cass - Faith Healer *DEAD*
Stan: Garth - Deputy *DEAD*
Brett: Prof - Werewolf *DEAD*
Locust: Cain - VT *DEAD*

Now who's lying..

[kionay]

Now who's lying..

you are?

[Sin]

So anyone care to offer any other strategies about how to play out the rest of the game? Or wanna just keep pointing at each other?

- Lynch Me
- Confirm Kionay is a legit Cop
- If Kionay dies Night 3, it's because Scribble didn't protect him and was lying, lynch Scribble Day 4
- If Scribble dies Night 3, it's because he protected Kionay, and Nemesis was lying, lynch Nemesis Day 4
- If Wolf Dies N3, I'd say he should target Nemesis with his one shot.


What else? Thoughts? We need strategies here.

[Blackmage]

First, if you're going to force a claim out of everyone, it's probably better to just request a mass claim. All that doing what happened yesterday is making some people look like scum, trying to slowly but surely force the cop out in the open. Before D3 started, we had 7 or 8 people unclaimed, and our cop well hidden. During the day, we systematically revealed our cop. If we had anything left, as Nem said, you're forcing them into the open. At best, you're forcing Mikey and myself to claim VT. Mass claiming is BEST done in an at least semi open, or with a flavour/role cop. In a closed, especially where it's simple to hide under "VT" Mass claiming outs power roles. At least in role maddness, people can lie for a positive reason. But, what is done is done, and wasn't all bad.

We've found that Blade claims Survivor, which while it's not harmful if it's true, can be used to explain a "not town", depending on how the mod does the results. However, this was a forced reveal, so could have been pre-emptive, or could have been true with a role he didn't even want to try to play as VT. Lying about his flavour could get him lie-lynched, but he could also be fairly sure no one would try to claim Mr. Vamp, so it's a safe fake claim.


isn't there the remote possibility that he's VT but lied to try to out someone?

Put simply, no. If he's a VT, the first person he was trying to out was... Our healer. Now, I know some of us have opinion on his play, but while it can be called scummy, has he every actively worked to lose? If he was trying to out someone, that would make it more likely he's actually scum.

The flavour on this game has been, interesting to say the least. That's what happens in a show where pretty much EVERYONE could be listed as evil. Who on the list couldn't be evil? Ed and Chuck?

Also, part of the reason people only type kion is, look at a qwerty keyboard. Look where kion is, and where ay is. I use two fingers here for kion, with minimal movement and two additional finger movements to hit the ay.

On the lynch, there IS an option that we haven't considered. How much do we trust Wolf? Not his claim, but his judgement? We can always lynch him, and let HIM decide who dies. DO NOT DO THIS UNLESS HE SAYS IT'S A GOOD IDEA. But, while this drops us by a townie, it drops us to an even number of players (supposing night kill) AND leaves the kill only on a townie. No input from scum at all. So I ask, do you feel lucky Wolf, or should we play this by the numbers? If we do this, he gets last vote, and writes who he is shooting. If for some reason they don't die, or if anyone else hammers him, we can lynch them tomorrow, and in the case of the hammer, wolf can shoot someone else, and hopefully can signal who that would be beforehand.

I'm against lynching Scribble. If he's what he says he is, he allows Kion one more investigate. Unless Nem is a Godfather Jailer. If he's not what he says he is, Kion is pretty much a foregone conclusion unless Nem can find the killer, since Nem's protection is useless there except to deny a kill. I want to lynch Nem, but don't think it's a good idea at the time. If he is town, he can stop kills by targeting anyone, which is powerful. Frankly, unless we do the wolf gambit, killing a person who didn't claim a power role is probably the best choice. No one overlaps in claims, and while Nem or Scrib could be lying, we know we have at least one wolf in sheep's clothing, and lynching them will not hurt the town's chances as a power role would. At the very least, someone like Sin would give some information.

[phil.™]

Wait, why lynch you though as oppose to me being lynched for the VT? As a VT, you have more to bring to the table than me.

[BladeTwinSwords]

Actually Blackmage, I rather enjoy playing as Survivor. It's difficult to play as but oh so rewarding when you win.

I am 100% sure that Pass is Double Voter and more than likely a townie so he is good.

We have far too many VT claims. There is no way in hell there would be this many VT's in a role game like this.

[Sin]

Because I was investigated by the Cop and confirmed Townie by the Cop. Killing me and showing everything that I INDEED am a VT, proves that the cop IS NOT insane.

Also, I didn't think Lynching Wolf would give him the ability to use his one shot, but I guess I was wrong!

- - - Updated - - -

And yes Blade, we've already come to the consensus that Pass is DBL Voter and most likely Town Sided.

[phil.™]

Because I was investigated by the Cop and confirmed Townie by the Cop. Killing me and showing everything that I INDEED am a VT, proves that the cop IS NOT insane.

Gotcha, makes sense.
I'm not for losing a prominent VT like you. Gotta be a better way.

[kionay]

Wait, why lynch you though as oppose to me being lynched for the VT? As a VT, you have more to bring to the table than me.

for once i agree with you completely :D

i can't forget how scummy phil was acting, i won't change my vote until there is a nearly unsurmountable pile of evidence that it's a bad play

- - - Updated - - -


Also, part of the reason people only type kion is, look at a qwerty keyboard. Look where kion is, and where ay is. I use two fingers here for kion, with minimal movement and two additional finger movements to hit the ay.

and burning the 1 calorie it would take for the extra 2 letters won't kill anyone >.>

[Sin]

I seriously think it's one of our best moves we can make as town right now. That second investigation on Nemesis was critical. I'm 90% on him being the Godfather.

Shit wait... is it possible that What would have given Nemesis Godfather AND Roleblocker abilities?

That would be retarded as fuck.

[Passarelli]

So is Phil getting lynched or what? I don't see why we are waiting for this. Scribbles should protect Kionay, and Kionay should look at whoever. If Kionay dies we will know Scribbles is scum. If Scribbles dies at night, we know he was telling the truth. After that, we could look again at Nem, or hopefully Kionay will come up with something tonight.

Nemesis, you could also protect/roleblock Kionay if you think Scribbles is lying. We could lynch him tomorrow.

We need to come up with a solid plan and get this show on the road.

[Blackmage]

Sin: That's part of the reason I said we need him to confirm. Epic mafia's hunter ONLY works if it's lynched.

It's possible What made him deathproof and Town lost when we started. However, it also may be just X-use investigation immune, or X-use jailer, or godfather/jailer till he has to make a kill himself. He could be the godfather and have someone else be the jailer, trying to draw the investigation. Someone else could have messed with the investigation, or Bobby could be a Naive cop. However, guessing what he is or what happened really won't help. I can keep going on about what it could be, and delve further into the realm of silly.

Pass: I think we're just making sure everyone is on the same page here.

[phil.™]

So is Phil getting lynched or what? I don't see why we are waiting for this.

What is your malfunction? If i get lynched, i'm confirmed VT, that's it. We cannot prove anything against nem or sin's claim.

[Passarelli]

I am more worried about your claim right now.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

I may have a solution to this dilemma but you will all have to wait tell I get off work and home. It will be about 2 more hours tell then.

[Wolfenstinger]

One - Blackmage is correct. If I get lynched, my ability may be used.
Two - I'll figure out if I wanna do a Russian Roulette by the end of today. ~8PM EST is when i'll post. Roughly.

[phil.™]

I may have a solution to this dilemma but you will all have to wait tell I get off work and home. It will be about 2 more hours tell then.

2 hour is worth waiting for if we have a solution with a plan.

[Sin]

There is no solution. No one can agree on anything because we all have our own opinions on what should happen apparently. Or mafia is just trying to steer the ship their own way.

[BladeTwinSwords]

There is no solution. No one can agree on anything because we all have our own opinions on what should happen apparently. Or mafia is just trying to steer the ship their own way.

The honest question is, who is lying and who is telling the truth.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

My plan is to lynch sin because he is a meanie and called me names and isnt attempting to work with anyone for anything T.T

- - - Updated - - -

no, but seriously.... to whom are we pointing the most aggressive fingers at. Can everyone post who they find the most suspicious atm?

[Sin]

Wtf Mikey that is your solution?

[SCRIBBLE]

Lynch me or sin to produce some results.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Wtf Mikey that is your solution?

lol no, my solution requires erveryone to post who they find the most suspicous. We will then tally who has the most votes from there and conclude who we lynch.

[SCRIBBLE]

So your plan is to play the game normally?

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

So your plan is to play the game normally?

not necessarily. Being that everyone has there own opinion on who to lynch, i want everyone to reflect on who they find the most suspicious. Who ever is found to be the most suspicous by the highest number of people, will be the person who we vote to lynch.

Or... we can continue to squabble for another month. Thats always another plan.

- - - Updated - - -

also, what exactly do we gain by lynching one of you two?

Apart from a body ofc.

[SCRIBBLE]

You do not read, I am not explaining something sin already explained. Mafia can still collaborate on someone to lynch because they know who mafia is.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

ok im posting it again for reference.

----------------------------

If we lynch Scribble this is how it will go:

- Scribble is dead and confirmed as Bodyguard Townie
- Proving Nem was lying and mafia aligned
- Kionay will die Night 3

If we lynch Phil:

- Phil is dead and confirmed VT
- Kionay will die Night 3

If we lynch Sin:

- Sin is dead and confirmed VT
- Proving Nem is the Godfather as he came up innocent
- Scribs (if Townie Bodyguard) could protect Kionay
- Kionay investigates Blackmage/Mikey/Aco/Phil

If we lynch Nem:

- Nem is dead and confirmed Townie Roleblocker
- Proving Scribs is bullshitting and couldn't even protect Aco as he stated
- Kionay dies Night 3

All in all, I believe lynching me would yield the best results, IF one of you faggots protects Kionay.

----------------------------------

First off, why would kionay die N3 if phil is lynched? If scribbs is telling the truth.. why cant he protect him N3 if phil is lynched?

What if scribbs gets lynched and ISNT confirmed bodyguard?
Better yet... what if our lynch dosnt confirm what we expect them to be after their claim?

How does you being lynched implicate nem?

thats all

[SCRIBBLE]

If I die and am town then nem is lying, implicating him as mafia. Same thing with sin. If I die an am not town then town still benefits lynching scum.

- - - Updated - - -

Is this shit really that hard to understand? Either you are stupid or playing stupid, aka scum.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

If I die and am town then nem is lying, implicating him as mafia. Same thing with sin. If I die an am not town then town still benefits lynching scum.

- - - Updated - - -

Is this shit really that hard to understand? Either you are stupid or playing stupid, aka scum.

yes actually because it is extremely vague. Im not defending nem by any means but i am having a hard time understanding what the fuck he lied about that would incriminate him if you turn up town after a lynch.

- - - Updated - - -

and for the record, those questions i asked were general, as in i was not personally asking but asking on behalf of everyone who appears to be at odds end with making a god damn decision.

[phil.™]

I'm not all for the pointing finger idea. We could possibly do it, in collaboration with sin's suggestion.
But still, ultimately either lynching sin or scribbs, even nem is top choice. This way, we could get some results.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

I'm not all for the pointing finger idea. We could possibly do it, in collaboration with sin's suggestion.
But still, ultimately either lynching sin or scribbs, even nem is top choice. This way, we could get some results.

and for sake of possible truths, scribbs shoud be the the last option. We need the cops results and if scribbs is in fact telling the truth, we need him at night.

[phil.™]

and for sake of possible truths, scribbs shoud be the the last option. We need the cops results and if scribbs is in fact telling the truth, we need him at night.

Oh of course, if sin or nem is voted, or even me, we need scribbs to protect kion to confirm his role as well.

Anyone else insight who to lynch?

[Nemesis]

The problem with keeping scrubs is he's lying and your cop dies tonight and you get nothing. There's a chance I block the goon tonight and we are safe.

If I block the goon the game is over as long as blade isn't something other than survivor.

[kionay]

The problem with keeping scrubs is he's lying and your cop dies tonight and you get nothing. There's a chance I block the goon tonight and we are safe.

If I block the goon the game is over as long as blade isn't something other than survivor.

only we don't know he's lying, unless you can provide hard proof we have to assume he MIGHT be telling the truth


now, if we all just got back a few pages we'll see Phil acting scummy like a motherfucker

i say we lynch him, if i die during the night then scrib isn't bodyguard (or nem is mafia roleblocking scrib), and if i live then scrib is obviously innocent and we find out about someone else

[phil.™]

The problem with keeping scrubs is he's lying and your cop dies tonight and you get nothing.
How are you so sure about this?

Also I have another idea.

Kion, if you really say you are a cop and I am not lynched, chances are you are going to investigate me, correct? If you plan on investigating me, then we should vote lynch me, as that would be a waste of an investigation for the night.
Scenario: Phil gets lynched, confirmed VT. Scribbs protects kion, if scribbs die, it will confirm his role, and proving nem wrong. Nem is lynched next day. Kion can now investigate someone else who is fishy, that's up to us to decide who is next fishy one.

Scenario: Phil does not get lynched. Scribbs protects kion, kion investigates phil, phil comes up as VT to him. Waste of an investigation.

This plan is so that the cop role is utilized to the max tonight, as it will be much needed. If kion plans to investigate me.. well that's stupid.
Thoughts?

[kionay]

How are you so sure about this?

Also I have another idea.

Kion, if you really say you are a cop and I am not lynched, chances are you are going to investigate me, correct? If you plan on investigating me, then we should vote lynch me, as that would be a waste of an investigation for the night.
Scenario: Phil gets lynched, confirmed VT. Scribbs protects kion, if scribbs die, it will confirm his role, and proving nem wrong. Nem is lynched next day. Kion can now investigate someone else who is fishy, that's up to us to decide who is next fishy one.

Scenario: Phil does not get lynched. Scribbs protects kion, kion investigates phil, phil comes up as VT to him. Waste of an investigation.

This plan is so that the cop role is utilized to the max tonight, as it will be much needed. If kion plans to investigate me.. well that's stupid.
Thoughts?

well since i want to lynch you then of course i don't want to investigate you, that'd just be silly

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

How are you so sure about this?

Also I have another idea.

Kion, if you really say you are a cop and I am not lynched, chances are you are going to investigate me, correct? If you plan on investigating me, then we should vote lynch me, as that would be a waste of an investigation for the night.
Scenario: Phil gets lynched, confirmed VT. Scribbs protects kion, if scribbs die, it will confirm his role, and proving nem wrong. Nem is lynched next day. Kion can now investigate someone else who is fishy, that's up to us to decide who is next fishy one.

Scenario: Phil does not get lynched. Scribbs protects kion, kion investigates phil, phil comes up as VT to him. Waste of an investigation.

This plan is so that the cop role is utilized to the max tonight, as it will be much needed. If kion plans to investigate me.. well that's stupid.
Thoughts?

however, you can just as easily be lying and im leaning towards that more then your innocence due to your behaviour. The purpose of investigating you is to confirm you are not mafia, not the other way around. Unless ofc... ou are trying to weasle your way out of being investigated if you arent lynched today...???

[phil.™]

however, you can just as easily be lying and im leaning towards that more then your innocence due to your behaviour. The purpose of investigating you is to confirm you are not mafia, not the other way around. Unless ofc... ou are trying to weasle your way out of being investigated if you arent lynched today...???

Why is your font so small? Lol, or is it just my iPhone?
No, what I am saying is, if kion is planning to investigate me if sin, nem, scribbs or blade is lynched, it's going to be a waste. Yes, we will get some results from the night through actions, but I feel like we could get more if he investigated someone else.
Does this makes sense any? Or does it just make sense in my head?
I know it sounds scummy as fuck saying "don't investigate me, it's a waste". That's why I'm throwing in the option to lynch me. Confirm my role, and let kion investigate someone else versus me.

- - - Updated - - -

Never mind about the font, it was my phone

[Passarelli]

We lynch Phil. If Phil is town sided then Scribbles protects Kionay. Kionay investigates Blackmage, Mikey, or whoever. Nem roleblocks the other one.

If Scribbles is lying, Kionay dies. If Scribbles and Kionay are both alive, mafia targeted someone else. If Scribbles dies, he was telling the truth.

If Phil is revealed to be scum, then Nem should likely play chicken with scum and roleblock/protect Kionay since Scribbles is likely scum also.

If scribbles is lying, Kionay dies. If Scribbles and Kionay are both alive, mafia targeted someone else. If Scribbles dies, he was telling the truth.

[phil.™]

We lynch Phil. If Phil is town sided then Scribbles protects Kionay. Kionay investigates Blackmage, Mikey, or whoever. Nem roleblocks the other one.

If Scribbles is lying, Kionay dies. If Scribbles and Kionay are both alive, mafia targeted someone else. If Scribbles dies, he was telling the truth.

If Phil is revealed to be scum, then Nem should likely play chicken with scum and roleblock/protect Kionay since Scribbles is likely scum also.

If scribbles is lying, Kionay dies. If Scribbles and Kionay are both alive, mafia targeted someone else. If Scribbles dies, he was telling the truth.

Scum, you would want me lynched.. Scum, I knew it.
Lol jk. Pass gets where I'm getting at.

There are lot of more possibilities that can come from it.

[Nemesis]

We lynch Phil. If Phil is town sided then Scribbles protects Kionay. Kionay investigates Blackmage, Mikey, or whoever. Nem roleblocks the other one.

If Scribbles is lying, Kionay dies. If Scribbles and Kionay are both alive, mafia targeted someone else. If Scribbles dies, he was telling the truth.

If Phil is revealed to be scum, then Nem should likely play chicken with scum and roleblock/protect Kionay since Scribbles is likely scum also.

If scribbles is lying, Kionay dies. If Scribbles and Kionay are both alive, mafia targeted someone else. If Scribbles dies, he was telling the truth.

vote Phil

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Why is your font so small? Lol, or is it just my iPhone?
No, what I am saying is, if kion is planning to investigate me if sin, nem, scribbs or blade is lynched, it's going to be a waste. Yes, we will get some results from the night through actions, but I feel like we could get more if he investigated someone else.
Does this makes sense any? Or does it just make sense in my head?
I know it sounds scummy as fuck saying "don't investigate me, it's a waste". That's why I'm throwing in the option to lynch me. Confirm my role, and let kion investigate someone else versus me.

- - - Updated - - -

Never mind about the font, it was my phone

just in your head. Being that you are the scummies person atm, if you are not lynched, it would be wise to investigate the scummiest player and confirm them, other wise we go into D4 with you unconfirmed and are prime lynch target.
However, that is entirely up to the cop.

[phil.™]

Oh and before I die, someone take note of those who really wanted me lynched, when I claimed VT, and only wanted a claim, nothing else... Pass and kion, possibly Mikey.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

ill play with your thought process then, if your lynched, who would be the better person to investigate? Preferably someone who is not likley to die in N3, i.e. scribbs

- - - Updated - - -

I didnt vote for you phil, nor have i expressed any passion in doing so. I just think your behavior was scummy as hell as it was identical to your behavior last game when you were scum.

[phil.™]

If I am not lynched, for peace of mind, fine waste a night on me.
I am useless at night though.

- - - Updated - - -

I understand I played scummy as hell. I just noticed those who were quiet. When I asked what they were, question was dodged. So I kept at it. Not once did they ask me to claim till I really got to them.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

If I am not lynched, for peace of mind, fine waste a night on me.
I am useless at night though.

- - - Updated - - -

I understand I played scummy as hell. I just noticed those who were quiet. When I asked what they were, question was dodged. So I kept at it. Not once did they ask me to claim till I really got to them.

That isnt entierly true. You were asked to claim, several hours before they caved in. Your response was, im not claiming until you two claim, if im not mistaken.

[BladeTwinSwords]

Are you absolutely sure you are willing to sacrifice yourself phil?

[phil.™]

That isnt entierly true. You were asked to claim, several hours before they caved in. Your response was, im not claiming until you two claim, if im not mistaken.
Oh yeah, I did say that. But didn't I say if pass claims then I will claim? And he still claimed after me..


Are you absolutely sure you are willing to sacrifice yourself phil?
Not per se, but better to take me out than sin or scribb.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Oh yeah, I did say that. But didn't I say if pass claims then I will claim? And he still claimed after me..


Not per se, but better to take me out than sin or scribb.

Your current vote count appears to be 3

Pass
Nem
Kion

[BladeTwinSwords]

Not per se, but better to take me out than sin or scribb.

Well the town are still at an advantage, so I will stick with town. I still won't vote for the time being as I am keeping a close eye on the voting.

If you all do not find a mafia by Day 5 and I'm still alive, then there is nothing more that I can do for you all.

[What]

Vote Count:


Nem: Scrib
Scrib: Scrib
Kion: Phil
Pass: Phil

[BladeTwinSwords]

By Day 5, I mean after the lynch.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

Vote Count:


Nem: Scrib
Scrib: Scrib
Kion: Phil
Pass: Phil

nem didnt unvote did he.

[phil.™]

No he did not unvote.

- - - Updated - - -

What do you all feel about this game play though? Gives town a little decent advantage?

[brett friggin favre]

***get on with it!***

[SCRIBBLE]

Just so you know, I die in the place of the person I protect. Scum can also be a double voter.

- - - Updated - - -

If the person I protect is targeted, I die. If I am roleblocked that person will die and I will look like a liar. Lynch me or sin you tards, nothing is gained from phil dying.

[Wolfenstinger]

I'm overdue in my response... but yeah i'll vote towards lynching Phil. Though... I believe I know who i'd shoot afterwards.

[phil.™]

If the person I protect is targeted, I die. If I am roleblocked that person will die and I will look like a liar. Lynch me or sin you tards, nothing is gained from phil dying.

Fuck me..

[Passarelli]

Phil, if there is anything I have been this game, quiet is not it. I just started a new job which doesn't give me computer access; so sure, there were pauses, but I have been pretty active every single night. They way you played was exceedingly scummy, and helped the mafia more then anyone else. Or how else do you interpret "I'm a VT but I'm going to force everyone (including the cop) to claim on day 3!" You had hardly said anything until day 3, and then only because people thought what you had said was scummy. That is why I still have my vote for you. Even if you are VT, you act like scum and the town would be better off without you.

People I trust:

Sin - Only person to agree day 1 and voted for someone other then Stan.

Kionay - Claimed Cop. Has been thinking along the same lines as me for much of the game.

Wolf - Cyber left enough clues that it would be absurd if he were scum.

People I am on the fence about:

Nem - Could be godfather. Barring that, I trust him.

Blackmage - Claimed VT. Rehashes information to make it easier for people to process but doesn't often share his opinion on what the data means. Hasn't voted yet and has played very passively.

Blade - Claimed 3rd party? He can work for or against us.

Aco - Has been pretty damn quiet.

Mikey - I am starting to trust you some now. At least more then Phil.

People I think are Scum: Phil, Scribble (if Phil is townie and Kionay lives, Scribbles would move to trusted)


Scribble, why would we vote the fucking bodyguard? We need you to protect Kionay. Phil claimed VT. I'd rather see him gone for his horrible play forcing out all of the power roles by day 3.

The only other viable option is to vote Sin, which would prove that Kionay is sane. Since Sin was the person to point this out, and from what I can tell has acted to help the town, I would rather keep him and toss the guy that is actively helping the Mafia.

[Wolfenstinger]

I'll vote tomorrow... morningish proll

[BladeTwinSwords]

***get on with it!***


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l1YmS_VDvMY

[phil.™]

Phil, if there is anything I have been this game, quiet is not it. I just started a new job which doesn't give me computer access; so sure, there were pauses, but I have been pretty active every single night. They way you played was exceedingly scummy, and helped the mafia more then anyone else. Or how else do you interpret "I'm a VT but I'm going to force everyone (including the cop) to claim on day 3!" You had hardly said anything until day 3, and then only because people thought what you had said was scummy. That is why I still have my vote for you. Even if you are VT, you act like scum and the town would be better off without you.

People I trust:

Sin - Only person to agree day 1 and voted for someone other then Stan.

Kionay - Claimed Cop. Has been thinking along the same lines as me for much of the game.

Wolf - Cyber left enough clues that it would be absurd if he were scum.

People I am on the fence about:

Nem - Could be godfather. Barring that, I trust him.

Blackmage - Claimed VT. Rehashes information to make it easier for people to process but doesn't often share his opinion on what the data means. Hasn't voted yet and has played very passively.

Blade - Claimed 3rd party? He can work for or against us.

Aco - Has been pretty damn quiet.

Mikey - I am starting to trust you some now. At least more then Phil.

People I think are Scum: Phil, Scribble (if Phil is townie and Kionay lives, Scribbles would move to trusted)


Scribble, why would we vote the fucking bodyguard? We need you to protect Kionay. Phil claimed VT. I'd rather see him gone for his horrible play forcing out all of the power roles by day 3.

The only other viable option is to vote Sin, which would prove that Kionay is sane. Since Sin was the person to point this out, and from what I can tell has acted to help the town, I would rather keep him and toss the guy that is actively helping the Mafia.

I would love to play fucking poker with you. You are the fucking easiest shit to read in this whole game.
With that said... keep your vote on me. You scum shithead.

[SCRIBBLE]

Haha right? Dude avoided my double voter scum comment

[phil.™]

I'm going to bed.
I would have wanted more insight on this idea.

Hope i'm not lynched by the morning, 7am-8am EST.

Night folks

[Passarelli]

What am I supposed to say to it Scribble? "I'm not scum. Period."? That is what Phil did and acts like it clears him. It is possible that double voter is scum, though that is more rare then town sided. I have done my best this game for town. I don't see how you trying to shift the blame off of Phil when he clearly made a very pro mafia play does anything but implicate you. Thank you for letting us know who else is mafia if Phil comes up guilty.

I had claimed before Phil, both flavor and role to try to take pressure off the person I felt 80% sure of being Cop. After he did finally claim as I asked, I hard claimed. (though looking back, mikey is right. I shouldn't have let him force me so I could protect the cop). Also, my flavor is pretty positive. I don't really know how else to convince you.

[SCRIBBLE]

I did not try to shift blame from anyone and that is what you insist upon... funny stuff. Also funny both sin and I provide scenarios that would benefit town regardless of outcome yet I am still suspect even after hard claim + actions.

[acolyte_to_jippity]

I did not try to shift blame from anyone and that is what you insist upon... funny stuff. Also funny both sin and I provide scenarios that would benefit town regardless of outcome yet I am still suspect even after hard claim + actions.

ok guys. can i have a list of reasons why sin's plan to lynch him is bad? assume he's not a jester. it seems to give us a shitload of info.

[SCRIBBLE]

Please read any post prior to this one made by sin. Fuck you for not paying attention.

[acolyte_to_jippity]

Please read any post prior to this one made by sin. Fuck you for not paying attention.

i did. and it sounded like a good plan. hence why i asked for a reason why we haven't gone with it yet. fuck you.

[Nemesis]

i did. and it sounded like a good plan. hence why i asked for a reason why we haven't gone with it yet. fuck you.

The problem is how many people are agreeing with it, meaning some of them are mafia. That may be looking too much into it though.

[DJ_MikeyRevile]

we are now officially on page 100.

[Nemesis]

we are now officially on page 100.

Your mother is on page 100.

[phil.™]

What am I supposed to say to it Scribble? "I'm not scum. Period."? That is what Phil did and acts like it clears him. It is possible that double voter is scum, though that is more rare then town sided. I have done my best this game for town. I don't see how you trying to shift the blame off of Phil when he clearly made a very pro mafia play does anything but implicate you. Thank you for letting us know who else is mafia if Phil comes up guilty.

I had claimed before Phil, both flavor and role to try to take pressure off the person I felt 80% sure of being Cop. After he did finally claim as I asked, I hard claimed. (though looking back, mikey is right. I shouldn't have let him force me so I could protect the cop). Also, my flavor is pretty positive. I don't really know how else to convince you.

What in the actual fuck part of "you seemed scummy at the time, i called you out; few other players called you out, and you fucking still dodged all question" not make me wonder or curious about you. I fucking said you claim first, then me. So don't give me that bs that you claimed first than me making me look scummy. That was the agreement. You really had nothing to hide, i mean being a double voter and all is not that great. It's good, but not great.

Are you illiterate or something? I'm making suggestions to help town, even willing to sacrifice myself so that town has a better chance of winning, and you still think i'm scum? You haven't done SHIT other than saying "lynch phil, why isnt he lynched yet". You sir, just went full retard.

[Sin]

The only problem I have with lynching Phil, is that IF Nemesis is lying, roleblocks Scribble, and kionay dies on Night 3. Scribble will look like a liar, as Nem will most likely say he roleblocked some other random person like "Mikey, because he's scummy".

Granted he COULD do the same if I were to be lynched, BUT we'd know for a fact that the Cop is not insane.

The situation really is between Scribble and Nem, because they're the ones with the contradicting abilities on Night 2. They're the ones we need to worry about come Day 4, if either of them are still alive.

One of them is lying, and I'm leaning towards Scribble, because a Godfather+Jailer role for Nem is OP as fuck and I wouldn't think that WHAT would put that in play.

[kionay]

What in the actual fuck part of "you seemed scummy at the time, i called you out; few other players called you out, and you fucking still dodged all question" not make me wonder or curious about you. I fucking said you claim first, then me. So don't give me that bs that you claimed first than me making me look scummy. That was the agreement. You really had nothing to hide, i mean being a double voter and all is not that great. It's good, but not great.

Are you illiterate or something? I'm making suggestions to help town, even willing to sacrifice myself so that town has a better chance of winning, and you still think i'm scum? You haven't done SHIT other than saying "lynch phil, why isnt he lynched yet". You sir, just went full retard.

at this point it's irrelevant if phil is scum or not (though i still think he is) because we need the info from his death, he's willing to die

so i think this matter is pretty well solved, let's get to lynching and move the fuck on so hopefully we don't have to reach page 200 -_-

[Sin]

I meant I'm leaning towards Nemesis as the one lying. He's most likely Godfather with no roleblocking power and has been lying since day 2 when he said he used his power on Aco.

Which is interesting, because gambling with an ability like that on a random player is suuuuper risky. So either Nemesis knew that Aco had no "ability" (because Aco is the Mafia Goon/Hitman) and was sure that Aco wouldn't put his claim on Blast.

In that scenario the past couple days' events make sense to me.

If you've all noticed we have no Crowley or Lucifer, prime candidates for a Godfather type role. Everyone claimed are basically minor roles aside from Dean, Sam, Castiel and Gabriel. It doesn't make sense to me, especially with the Flavor text.

I believe Nemesis and Aco are mafia, due to Nemesis' claim of "Jailer" and using his ability on Aco Night 1 because it was SAFE, and his contradiction with Scribble. Not to mention he's been playing scummy this entire game. I'm going to go with my original gut feeling from Day 1.

VOTE NEMESIS