[C9] Mafia Game #1

[Erdenay]

speaking as an outside witness i think a reset starting at day 1 should be considered. seems most people didn't understand the whole "let the dude speak" thing.

but with sin's identity being revealed...hmm.. :/

That's actually not a bad idea. If you guys want, I can switch up roles/names and we can start this over. Thoughts?

[What]

I'm good with that, but maybe spice it up with some fancy roles, i know its just a first time through, but it would be good to make it fun

[CYBER]

That's actually not a bad idea. If you guys want, I can switch up roles/names and we can start this over. Thoughts?

lol, i still don't have no fucking idea what's going on -.- what does "let the dude speak"
nway? ergh... ffs, sure o guess? lol, that moment when u feel more of an idiot that normally...

[Nemesis]

I'm down for a restart, I actually assumed that once we voted to lynch him he'd get to speak, there was always a trial in the version i played before, for everyone would vote to lynch whoever, then they would get a trial where everyone would vote again either innocent or guilty and then that person explodes or not.

So ya, I'm down for a restart.

[Sin]

This reminds me of trouble in terrorist town, except it's more like the KKK hating on negros.

[brett friggin favre]

This reminds me of trouble in terrorist town, except it's more like the KKK hating on negros.

and you're the first negro out. gee, how fitting.

p.s. if you guys do restart, i HIGHLY SUGGEST you read at least the basics here if you haven't already: http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Newbie_Guide

[Nemesis]

and you're the first negro out. gee, how fitting.

p.s. if you guys do restart, i HIGHLY SUGGEST you read at least the basics here if you haven't already: http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Newbie_Guide

Shouldn't we also know some of the roles going in? not so much the mafia but Tom said there was a chance there were 5 townies and 2 mafioso's. At that point don't you instantly loose unless you get lucky? all people have to do is keep quiet and kill someone each night, but at least if we know there's a sheriff and an investigator we can start from there.

[CYBER]

Shouldn't we also know some of the roles going in? not so much the mafia but Tom said there was a chance there were 5 townies and 2 mafioso's. At that point don't you instantly loose unless you get lucky? all people have to do is keep quiet and kill someone each night, but at least if we know there's a sheriff and an investigator we can start from there.

thats what i thought was happening at first. As in it was uncontestable that it's 2 mafia and 5 townies in ALL our ibis games. But after reading about it, its better to keep it random (C9 or F11) because people were cheating the system by knowing that there is definitely a cop and a doctor. The cop would then claim his role publicly, and the doctor be hidden. Everyone would vote 'no lynch' every day until the cop finds a suspect. Should the mafia try to kill the cop, the doctor will always protect him every night. Rince and repeat. It gets hard for mafia to find the doctor, and even if they did, the cop would know many innocent/guilty names by then. And mafia couldt vote on threads other than no lynch just to blend in... So the randomness is intentional so thatthe cop doesnt know if there's a doc that MIGHT protect him. And people cant tell if the cop actually found a guilty man when voting... Etc.. Tldr? No. Keep it random. Adds strategy