Supernatural Mafia

[SCRIBBLE]

if stan is a power role then he is useless as such, town or mafia. my vote stands.

[What]

For Reference:

Vote Count:

Pass: Nem
OB: Stan
Sin: Nem
Stan: No lynch
Scrib: Stan
Nem: Stan
Phil: Stan
Brett: Stan
Blade: Stan
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I will be out for about an hour or so, if a lynch occurs and im not around, just be respectful of the rules and stop talking to eachother until i come back.

[Nemesis]

And incase anyone can't count that's two more.

[CYBER]

For Reference:

Vote Count:

Pass: Nem
OB: Stan
Sin: Nem
Stan: No lynch
Scrib: Stan
Nem: Stan
Phil: Stan
Brett: Stan
Blade: Stan
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I will be out for about an hour or so, if a lynch occurs and im not around, just be respectful of the rules and stop talking to eachother until i come back.

do u want me to send u my files for the last game? I currently also have a count with the same format as before, just to make it visually easy for those who cant count (as nem puts it)

[What]

If you want to keep track of the votes yourself, that is fine. Do not post your damn chart here.

[CYBER]

he never claimed VT... cyber is just putting out information with no base.

Brett already answered you why I strongly believe Stan is a VT. Just like how blackmage used my first "oopsie" lynch count in last game, the mere fact that What didn't have to intervene to instantly replace stan who's being banwagoned hard shows that either What STRONGLY believes in his balancing to the point where killing off a possibly important role right off the bat is perfectly fine, OR stan wasn't that important to begin with... It was the same argument that someone threw at me in the previous game when i called for a deadline to my dismay. You tell me.

the base is that What insinuated that this situation is of little importance. he has a horse in the stable but wants to save it for a more important race. that tells us stan's not a power role or mafia, as we thought.

Pretty much my chain of thinking when I wanted to WAIT on lynching an afk, instead of immediately lynching without baiting out different outcomes to pull info from.

bingo.

nem, you're lucky yet again. i count 5 lives left, pussy.

Vote: Stan

I dont understand this reasoning. You just did what nem did. I mean thank u for being intelligent enough to understand why i posted that assumption, but You SECOND my opinion that stan is a VT... yet go straight ahead to condemn what you believe is a VT to death? instead of pointing fingers at someone who could possibly be a scum?

If Stan's a VT why not spare him and vote someone else? If he does end up being replaced, it'll just be another free vote for Townies. Not understanding the logic here.

Yep, policy lynch.

Vote Stan

Policy lynches are NEVER good... especially when we know he is most likely a VT... PRO TOWN. i'd say we keep him around for the extra vote when need be? and focus on trying to find scummy behavior?




---
The good news is that CURRENTLY, because we are only 2 votes away, we can clearly see that there ISNT a combination of any of those 2 roles at the SAME TIME: self hammerer, double voter, forced hammerer. Or else 2 of them would have forced a lynch by now.

- - - Updated - - -

If you want to keep track of the votes yourself, that is fine. Do not post your damn chart here.

love meh. u were the one that wanted my files before, jsut saying

that's fine tho, will keep that to myself, easier to see the bandwagoning orders .

[brett friggin favre]

I dont understand this reasoning. You just did what nem did. I mean thank u for being intelligent enough to understand why i posted that assumption, but You SECOND my opinion that stan is a VT... yet go straight ahead to condemn what you believe is a VT to death? instead of pointing fingers at someone who could possibly be a scum?

Policy lynches are NEVER good... especially when we know he is most likely a VT... PRO TOWN. i'd say we keep him around for the extra vote when need be? and focus on trying to find scummy behavior?

i'm glad we got irish out of last game. his actions proved he was useless, as have stan's. if you can't so much as read the rules...why are you here? i see him as a hazard as much as possible help, he could easily throw in a vote backing mafia without knowing it.

[CYBER]

to my note about the voters, i meant that the forced hammerer, if any, is not in the remaining non-voters...

also i forgot to answer at Sin's quote...

I agree with what sin is saying here... bussing what we believe is a VT to death when we know we could be finding better targets or scummy behaviour...



Like brett, you told Nemesis before that "there you are nemesis, your shit stinks, but someone else's shit stinks even more..." ... and when YOU believe that stan is a VT, you keep going for a vote on stan instead of following up with what u accused nemesis of doing over and over again?
wth man... i could use an explanation if u dont mind

- - - Updated - - -

i'm glad we got irish out of last game. his actions proved he was useless, as have stan's. if you can't so much as read the rules...why are you here? i see him as a hazard as much as possible help, he could easily throw in a vote backing mafia without knowing it.

ok sry i kinda posted while u posted...


i see what you mean about him possibly being a hassle... but not yet. unless the MAJORITY of townies went full tard, his vote wont be so influencial at the start. but might be later on , especially if mafia will very like not be focusing on stan at this point... for the same reasons Sin isn't a priority either i believe... so us killing him off so fast, albeit a reasonable sacrifice in case he fucks up later, still isn't a priority right now as opposed to keep pressing on the people who STILL STINK if u know what i mean.

if we hit a dead end there... THEN we can sacrifice stan as a VERY last resort,,, almost as how NL is a very last resort.

[brett friggin favre]

to my note about the voters, i meant that the forced hammerer, if any, is not in the remaining non-voters...

also i forgot to answer at Sin's quote...

I agree with what sin is saying here... bussing what we believe is a VT to death when we know we could be finding better targets or scummy behaviour...



Like brett, you told Nemesis before that "there you are nemesis, your shit stinks, but someone else's shit stinks even more..." ... and when YOU believe that stan is a VT, you keep going for a vote on stan instead of following up with what u accused nemesis of doing over and over again?
wth man... i could use an explanation if u dont mind

- - - Updated - - -


ok sry i kinda posted while u posted...


i see what you mean about him possibly being a hassle... but not yet. unless the MAJORITY of townies went full tard, his vote wont be so influencial at the start. but might be later on , especially if mafia will very like not be focusing on stan at this point... for the same reasons Sin isn't a priority either i believe... so us killing him off so fast, albeit a reasonable sacrifice in case he fucks up later, still isn't a priority right now as opposed to keep pressing on the people who STILL STINK if u know what i mean.

if we hit a dead end there... THEN we can sacrifice stan as a VERY last resort,,, almost as how NL is a very last resort.

we saw last game that nem despite playing scummy as fuck, was town-sided, and a power role as well. for that, he's stupid. his input can be valuable though. i can't trust nem's play to mean that he's scum, and his input is more valuable than stan's. he's right up there on my list, but i'll give him a night at least and see what he brings to the table tomorrow.

[SCRIBBLE]

Time for sleep. Stop dragging out the inevitable and grasping at straws. If not stan then vote SOMEONE. Stan is useless regardless as I doubt he would be around enough to cast a vote in the future. The only drawback to him being a VT is we lose a number in the majority figure. If he is a power role then he is a useless power role. You can ignore me but every policy lynch I have suggested on the first day in any mafia game I participated in ended up being spot on... the player is either useless or hiding something which is typically something anti-town.

- - - Updated - - -

useless as a power role****