Blade's Soft Drink Themed Mafia Game

[What]

So a few things.

Both Joker and Phil have been playing incredibly stupid. I can not think that is simply a case of being new or really that dumb. Pretty much mafia 101, the people who act stupid like they have no idea what is going on and keep suggesting terrible things are almost always mafia, or Mikey. That being said, on Assassin.

Day 1 he was a suspect for me, the way he was acting, but he is not, from all I have seen, particularly good at this game. Nem did not come after him initially, Assassin came at Nem, trying to take the high ground as Nem is a complete ass, and Nem responded in kind. Now, Assassin claimed waaaaaay tooo early, which could be a last ditch effort of, "well I'm boned lets see if I can help out the mafia." That being said, Roleblocker is the most basic mafia class, and I would like to think that if the Mafia attack was blocked, flavor would have hinted at something, there is not even a trace of that. The mafia attack is a mute point anyways if they attacked me. Also, Nem could be a lyncher, remember that role? good times, but Blade would be extra douchy to put that role back in play. Nem being mafia at this point makes little sense, as such a gambit would not pay dividends. Also, relatively certain it would be a 8 3 1 setup with 12 people, 2 mafia is way to low for that many people in role madness.

Assassin, who did you attempt to investigate last night?

[CYBER]

Couldn't it be possible that nem is a rb, but rb for mafia? And mafia just did a no-kill to make it seem like whoever they targeted to be role blocked as a mafia?
Just trying to get other ideas here other than 1 thing to go by.

Although RB is a generically used mafia role, and thus possible to be the case, it is VERY unlikely that he would bring himself into spotlight like that to call out assassin for no reason. Especially after him being one of the early adopters of "Just because you are a roleblocker, or confirmed roleblocker, does not mean you are town, if anything you are more like to be a mafia goon" philosophy.
But for him to put himself on the spot like that is very non-mafia-like trait at the moment.
And just to tell you something, although it sounds good in theory, it is generally a very bad play to not attack as a mafia, no matter how convoluted it sounds, because you're simply wasting a -1 townie chance for the sake of creating confusion.
In ibis, you don't need to pretend to kill to cause confusion, the players will get confused no matter what, so the whole charade serves no purpose but to satisfy a personal epeen that you didn't need to kill first night. That's all.
And although Niggasis is the definition of "Full of epeens", he wouldn't pull that entire elaborate plan by wasting a -1 on the townies just to confuse us... Claims like Asassin's and your motion for the cop to CC it is enough confusion on its own lol...

The mafia attack is a mute point anyways if they attacked me. Also, Nem could be a lyncher, remember that role?

surely you mean MOOT point.
or do you SPECIFICALLY mean MUTE point, which is defined as “When somebody in a group makes a good suggestion, but somehow nobody hears it.” . Which is a totally different thing.
Also maybe you can elaborate on that.


Also, isn't a lyncher treated like a joker as a bastard role ? because it ends the game? or simply gives away a partial useless win?

[CYBER]

to add on onto the Phil argument :
if anything, if there's a mafia, that WASN't roleblocked by nemesis (aka assassin), nor denied by a doctor or bodyguard or faith healers, or dodged by commuter or hider or vest or bulletproof or other crap,
then they would have to have attacked WHAT as the serial killer.

Note:
This is under the assumption that if mafia attacked What , while What attacked the bomb, only bomb and What would die, not the mafia attacker.

There are cases where the bomb would literally take out everyone : itself, its attacker the SK, and its attacker's attackers etc, simply for all being at the same location.

I am going to ask Blade about this ruling just to be on the safe side, but the latter is usually observed more towards EpicMafia rather than mafiascum.

So again, highly more likely that mafia at least ATTEMPTED to kill someone, rather than holding their dicks around and hoping for the best.

- - - Updated - - -

Cyber

Well shit, I was typing a post asking you to humour me and telling me what you got as a result, but I remembered that your action got blocked.

Maybe next time.

[Assassin]

to add on onto the Phil argument :
if anything, if there's a mafia, that WASN't roleblocked by nemesis (aka assassin), nor denied by a doctor or bodyguard or faith healers, or dodged by commuter or hider or vest or bulletproof or other crap,
then they would have to have attacked WHAT as the serial killer.

Note:
This is under the assumption that if mafia attacked What , while What attacked the bomb, only bomb and What would die, not the mafia attacker.

There are cases where the bomb would literally take out everyone : itself, its attacker the SK, and its attacker's attackers etc, simply for all being at the same location.

I am going to ask Blade about this ruling just to be on the safe side, but the latter is usually observed more towards EpicMafia rather than mafiascum.

So again, highly more likely that mafia at least ATTEMPTED to kill someone, rather than holding their dicks around and hoping for the best.

- - - Updated - - -



Well shit, I was typing a post asking you to humour me and telling me what you got as a result, but I remembered that your action got blocked.

Maybe next time.

Yeah it said your investigation has returned nadda results (obv paraphrasing so I don't get modkilled)

- - - Updated - - -

Also as a note, Nem I may have called you a bunch of shit like you do me always, but I NEVER voted for you, nor did my rb actions cause this shit.

[CYBER]

nor did my rb actions cause this shit.

wha? rephrase.

[Assassin]

So a few things.

Both Joker and Phil have been playing incredibly stupid. I can not think that is simply a case of being new or really that dumb. Pretty much mafia 101, the people who act stupid like they have no idea what is going on and keep suggesting terrible things are almost always mafia, or Mikey. That being said, on Assassin.

Day 1 he was a suspect for me, the way he was acting, but he is not, from all I have seen, particularly good at this game. Nem did not come after him initially, Assassin came at Nem, trying to take the high ground as Nem is a complete ass, and Nem responded in kind. Now, Assassin claimed waaaaaay tooo early, which could be a last ditch effort of, "well I'm boned lets see if I can help out the mafia." That being said, Roleblocker is the most basic mafia class, and I would like to think that if the Mafia attack was blocked, flavor would have hinted at something, there is not even a trace of that. The mafia attack is a mute point anyways if they attacked me. Also, Nem could be a lyncher, remember that role? good times, but Blade would be extra douchy to put that role back in play. Nem being mafia at this point makes little sense, as such a gambit would not pay dividends. Also, relatively certain it would be a 8 3 1 setup with 12 people, 2 mafia is way to low for that many people in role madness.

Assassin, who did you attempt to investigate last night?

Cyber